Actor-producer Vidnyan Mane has said he will begin criminal proceedings against music composer Palash Muchhal, weeks after the Bombay High Court dismissed a defamation case Muchhal had filed against him. The legal fight between the two men, which first became public in January 2026, has now moved through multiple courts in Maharashtra. Mane, a childhood friend of Indian women’s cricket captain Smriti Mandhana, says the high court’s order sends a clear message about false cases being used for publicity.
The dispute centres on money Mane says he invested in Muchhal’s film Nazariya, and on allegations of caste-based remarks during a confrontation in November 2025. Muchhal has denied all accusations and his legal team has called the case against him a “publicity stunt”.
The Defamation Case That Was Dismissed
The Bombay High Court dismissed the defamation suit filed by Palash Muchhal against Vidnyan Mane, according to Mane. The actor-producer said the case was dismissed because of procedural problems. “No one is above the law, and compliance with judicial procedures is mandatory for everyone,” Mane said.
Muchhal had sent Mane a ₹10 crore defamation notice before filing the suit. His lawyer, Shreyansh Mithare, had earlier said the defamation case was filed in February 2026 and that the high court issued a restraining order on February 11, 2026, stopping Mane from speaking against Muchhal in the media.
Mane’s response after the dismissal was direct. “This verdict conveys an important message: people should not file baseless and false cases in court merely to generate publicity,” he said. He added that he now plans to start criminal proceedings against Muchhal.
What Vidnyan Mane Plans To Do Next
Mane has said he will bring forward what he calls the “fabricated and imaginary stories” Muchhal has told so far. He also said he wants the truth to reach Muchhal’s family members so they can understand the reality of his conduct.
“Very soon, I will initiate the necessary and appropriate judicial as well as criminal proceedings in this matter, strictly through lawful channels,” Mane said. The statement makes clear that Mane intends to keep the fight inside the legal system and not in the media alone.
The Money Dispute Behind the Case
The financial part of the dispute goes back to 2023 and 2024. Mane says he met Muchhal in Sangli in December 2023 and later transferred money for the film Nazariya. The amount is described differently across reports: some say ₹25 lakh, while Mane has spoken of ₹40 lakh in total.
According to Mane’s complaint, Muchhal promised him good returns and also offered him a role in the film. Mane says the film was completed but his money was not returned despite repeated follow-ups. He has said Muchhal stopped responding after a point.
Mane has also made personal allegations against Muchhal, including that Muchhal was caught cheating on Smriti Mandhana. Muchhal has strongly denied those claims and called them baseless and factually incorrect.
The Caste Remarks Allegation and the SC/ST Case
A second and more serious legal track opened in May 2026, when Mane filed a complaint under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act at Sangli City Police Station. The complaint says the incident happened on November 22, 2025, at a toll plaza on the Sangli-Ashta road during an argument over the money.
Mane has said Muchhal made caste-based remarks against him during that confrontation. “He made a few casteist slurs and he also said, ‘People in MP don’t even stand people like you (from your caste),’” Mane told Times of India.
Police registered the case under Section 3(1)(R)(S) of the SC/ST Act and under sections of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita related to criminal intimidation and intentional insult. Mane has said Muchhal should be arrested soon because the offence is non-bailable.
Muchhal’s Anticipatory Bail Was Rejected
Muchhal suffered a legal setback in July 2026 when the Sangli Sessions Court rejected his anticipatory bail plea in the SC/ST case. The order was passed on Friday, July 10, 2026.
Muchhal’s lawyer, Advocate Abhijit Desai, confirmed the development and said the legal team plans to challenge the order. “Yes the news is true and we plan to challenge the order,” Desai said. The SC/ST Act places strict conditions on anticipatory bail in atrocity cases, which made the bail plea a difficult one for Muchhal’s side.
How Muchhal’s Lawyer Has Responded
Muchhal’s legal team has consistently rejected Mane’s claims. Lawyer Shreyansh Mithare called the atrocity case a “pressure tactic” and questioned why Mane waited months to make the caste remarks allegation. “If that happened on November 22, and now we are in May, why was no complaint made until now?” Mithare told NDTV. “Earlier, he only spoke about a financial dispute, but he never brought up any allegation of caste-based remarks. This clearly shows that his intentions are not genuine and that he is merely seeking publicity”.
Mithare also said Mane was summoned twice by the high court in the defamation case but did not appear. According to the lawyer, the atrocity complaint was filed to pressure Muchhal into withdrawing the defamation case or reaching a settlement.
Smriti Mandhana’s Connection to the Case
Smriti Mandhana, the India women’s cricket team captain, is linked to the dispute through her relationships with both men. Vidnyan Mane is described in multiple reports as her childhood friend from Sangli. Palash Muchhal is her former fiancé.
Muchhal and Mandhana were set to marry on November 23, 2025, in Sangli. The wedding was called off, and on December 7, 2025, the couple announced their separation. The legal dispute between Mane and Muchhal surfaced weeks after that cancellation, in January 2026.
Mandhana has not made a public statement about the criminal case or the defamation dismissal. Muchhal’s lawyer said in May 2026 that the legal team was “not aware” of Mane’s association with Mandhana and that Mandhana “would be the best person to clarify”.
What the Case Means for Both Men
For Palash Muchhal, the rejection of anticipatory bail in an SC/ST Act case is a serious legal development. The case remains active at the police level in Sangli, and Muchhal’s legal team has said it will challenge the bail order in a higher court. Muchhal completed the shooting of Nazariya in 2024, and the film remains unreleased.
You May Also Like
For Vidnyan Mane, the dismissal of Muchhal’s defamation suit removes one legal pressure point. His stated plan to begin criminal proceedings adds a new front to a dispute that already includes a police case under the SC/ST Act and a financial cheating complaint. Mane has framed the high court’s dismissal as a validation of his position, while Muchhal’s side continues to call the allegations against him false and publicity-driven.
Also Read: On Anurag Kashyap’s Sets, Nobody Could ‘Smell the Authority’
Stay with VvipTimes for clear, fact-checked updates on the court cases and legal developments that shape the entertainment world.







































Leave a Reply