All’s Fair Ending Explained: Dina’s Arrest and Carrington’s Final Move

The finale of All’s Fair delivered shocking personal betrayals and a major legal cliffhanger. Over the two-part finale, which aired on December 9, the story moved from a tense courtroom drama to an intensely personal war of revenge among a tight-knit group of lawyers. The episode concluded with a key character being arrested for murder while another completed a long-gestating plan for vengeance. Here is a full breakdown of the high-stakes ending.

The Plan to Bring a New Partner into the Firm

In the first part of the finale, Allura’s law firm, LVLUP Legal, faced a critical decision about its future. The firm needed to bring in a new, active partner to help manage a growing caseload.

The partners’ first choice was Dina Standish. However, after the death of her husband, Dina declined a full partnership. She explained that her priorities had shifted and she wanted more time for herself, offering instead to serve in an advisory role. With Dina stepping back, the firm needed another candidate.

Dina herself surprisingly suggested Carrington Lane, despite their long and complicated history of rivalry. Dina believed Carrington’s brilliant legal mind could be an asset, and she saw the potential to heal old professional wounds. This suggestion immediately divided the other partners—Allura, Liberty, and Emerald—who were wary of Carrington’s motives.

Carrington’s Alarming Transformation and Motives

Carrington Lane had a clear plan from the very beginning, which she revealed in a private moment: she aimed to join the firm only to destroy it from within as revenge against the women she felt had ruined her life. Her fixation escalated to an alarming extreme during the finale.

After a brief affair with Allura’s ex-husband, Chase Munroe, Carrington was deeply hurt when he accidentally called her by Allura’s name during an encounter. This incident pushed her to make a drastic change. She hired top stylists to transform her appearance to look exactly like Allura Grant.

“She called it her tribute to her rival, though everyone saw it as psychological warfare.”

When Carrington arrived at the firm with her new look, the confrontation was immediate. Allura called her a knockoff and vowed she would never join the firm. However, Carrington calculated correctly that Allura cared more about the firm’s success than personal feelings and would eventually consider her for the partnership based on skill alone.

Liberty’s Crushed Wedding Plans

Amid the partnership battle, Liberty Ronson was planning her wedding to Reggie Ramirez. However, her friends discovered serious problems when they looked into his background.

As a wedding gift, Emerald Greene ran a deep background check on Reggie. She found that he had taken out a massive loan using his future earnings as collateral and was close to financial ruin. This discovery put his insistence on a prenuptial agreement in a new light; it was likely an attempt to protect Liberty from his debt, not a sign of distrust.

When Liberty learned the full truth from Allura, she was devastated. While she claimed not to care about the money, she could not accept being lied to by her future husband. The trust was shattered, and she called off the wedding, returning the engagement ring to a heartbroken Reggie.

Carrington’s Calculated Manipulation of the Partners

Carrington worked systematically to turn the partners against each other and isolate her main obstacle, Dina. She first targeted Liberty, exploiting her insecurities about fitting in with her American friends.

Carrington gave Liberty an expensive wedding gift and suggested that Allura and Emerald mocked her choices behind her back. She manipulated Liberty into choosing bridesmaid dresses that the others found ridiculous, creating a major rift. After successfully driving this wedge, Carrington privately crossed Liberty’s name off her revenge list.

With Liberty temporarily on her side, Carrington then focused her full attention on Dina. After Dina vowed to campaign against Carrington joining the firm, Carrington launched a sophisticated campaign to make Dina appear mentally unstable.

Her tactics included:

• Fabricated Evidence: She showed the partners alarming text messages she claimed were from Dina, including one that discussed suicidal thoughts.
• A Coerced Witness: She brought in Dina’s former maid, Esperanza, who claimed Dina had physically assaulted her. It was strongly implied Carrington threatened to have Esperanza’s undocumented family deported to secure this false testimony.
• A Forged Will: Carrington presented a handwritten will that left most of Dina’s fortune to Esperanza—a document Dina insisted she never wrote.

Dina desperately defended herself, admitting to grief and memory lapses after her husband’s death but denying all of Carrington’s specific accusations. She begged her friends to see that they were being manipulated.

Detective Morrow’s Investigation Comes to a Head

Throughout the season, Detective Connie Morrow had been investigating the murder of Lloyd Walton, the man who had sexually assaulted Emerald. In the finale, she interrogated Emerald and Liberty, presenting new evidence that the killing was an act of vengeance.

Detective Morrow had evidence pointing to someone at the firm, though she kept specifics close. Earlier in the episode, Dina had forcefully interrupted the interrogation, accusing Morrow of harassment and demanding she leave without a warrant. Morrow left but promised to return with solid proof.

The Final Confrontation and Shocking Arrest

All the storylines collided in the firm’s conference room. As the partners—Allura, Liberty, and Emerald—confronted Dina about Carrington’s accusations regarding her mental state, Dina continued to plead her case.

At that moment, Detective Morrow arrived with two uniformed officers. She burst into the office and placed Dina Standish under arrest for the murder of Lloyd Walton.

“Carrington calmly crossed Dina’s name off her list, confirming she had engineered the setup.”

This final move confirmed that Carrington had orchestrated the entire situation. With Dina, the firm’s most powerful protector, taken away in handcuffs, Carrington’s path to joining the firm was cleared.

Where the Story Leaves Off for a Potential Season 2

The finale left major questions unanswered. Dina sits in jail for a crime she insists she did not commit. With Dina gone, the firm has lost its most formidable member, making it vulnerable to Carrington’s influence.

Carrington appears to have succeeded in the first major phase of her revenge plan. The show has been renewed for a second season, which is scheduled to begin filming in spring 2026. The first season became one of Hulu’s biggest scripted debuts in three years, ensuring the story will continue.

The season proved how quickly power can shift and how revenge can dismantle even the strongest alliances.

Also Read: Little Disasters Cast and Characters: The Faces Behind the Paranoia

---