Fans of the Marvel Cinematic Universe have been wondering if Agatha All Along will return for a second season on Disney+. The Kathryn Hahn-led series became a surprise hit when it debuted in late 2024, earning strong reviews and developing a dedicated fanbase. But recent comments from cast members and Marvel executives have created confusion about whether Agatha Harkness will lead her own show again or if her story will continue elsewhere in the MCU.
The mixed messages started when actor Patti LuPone, who played Lilia Calderu in the series, stated firmly that a second season was not happening. But Marvel’s head of streaming, Brad Winderbaum, later suggested the door remains open for more episodes. Here is the latest information about what is really going on with the potential return of Agatha All Along.
What Patti LuPone Said About No Season 2
The most direct statement about Agatha All Along not continuing came from Patti LuPone herself. During an appearance on SiriusXM’s Andy Cohen Live in January 2025, LuPone was asked directly about the possibility of a second season. Her response left little room for interpretation .
“There won’t be one,” LuPone said bluntly when asked about Agatha All Along season 2.
LuPone also shared that showrunner Jac Schaeffer had been clear with the cast from the very beginning. According to LuPone, Schaeffer told everyone involved that the series was designed as a one-season story. The actor explained that Schaeffer finds the workload of writing multiple seasons overwhelming and prefers creating limited series with clear beginnings, middles, and ends .
This approach matches what Schaeffer did with WandaVision, the 2021 series that introduced Agatha Harkness to the MCU. Despite that show’s massive success, Schaeffer also declined to do a second season of WandaVision, choosing to let it stand as a complete story .
Marvel Exec Brad Winderbaum Offers Different View
Despite LuPone’s definitive statement, Marvel executive Brad Winderbaum has offered a more hopeful perspective. In an interview with Entertainment Weekly in February 2025, Winderbaum, who serves as Marvel’s head of streaming, television, and animation, discussed how the studio views projects like Agatha All Along .
Winderbaum explained that some shows are seen as having “linear series potential” rather than being strictly limited series. When specifically asked about Agatha All Along, he said the show is “concept based,” which means it could continue if the right story emerges .
“Yes, a second season for sure is something that we would want to do, but let’s not rush it. Let’s get the right idea and then make it.” – Brad Winderbaum to Entertainment Weekly
Winderbaum also responded playfully when asked about LuPone’s comments, saying “What’d she say?” with a smile, suggesting that Marvel is not ready to officially close the door on more episodes .
Jac Schaeffer’s Position On Second Seasons
At the center of this confusion is showrunner Jac Schaeffer, who created both WandaVision and Agatha All Along. Schaeffer has built a reputation for telling complete stories in a single season rather than stretching narratives across multiple years .
According to multiple reports, when Marvel originally wanted to do a second season of WandaVision, Schaeffer turned them down. She has taken the same approach with Agatha All Along, viewing it as a self-contained story about Agatha Harkness finding her way after the events of WandaVision .
However, Schaeffer did recently comment on potential storylines for a second season, revealing that retaining the two-part finale in its “non-traditional finale” form was a challenge during production. This suggests that while she may not want to do a traditional second season, she has thought about where the story could go .
Kathryn Hahn’s Hopes For Agatha’s Future
Kathryn Hahn, who plays Agatha Harkness, has been careful not to confirm or deny a second season. During appearances on the Golden Globes red carpet in early 2025, Hahn was asked about the show’s future but did not give a clear answer .
Hahn did express some dissatisfaction with playing the witch in a limited way and speculated about a potential trilogy featuring Agatha and the WandaVision team. This suggests that while she may not know about a second season of Agatha All Along specifically, she expects to play the character again in some form .
In other interviews, Hahn has shared who she would like to see Agatha face in future MCU appearances. Rather than fighting physical powerhouses like the Hulk, Hahn wants Agatha to battle foes in the realm of mysticism and magic .
“Doctor Strange or Loki could be really fun… mischievous magic… Other, like a wizard or mischief maker- also of course, Scarlet Witch.” – Kathryn Hahn on desired adversaries for Agatha
What The Conflicting Reports Actually Mean
When looking at all the available information, a clearer picture emerges. The confusion comes from different ways of thinking about what a “season 2” means versus characters simply returning.
Patti LuPone’s statement that “there won’t be one” likely refers specifically to a traditional second season of Agatha All Along with the same cast and creative team continuing the exact story from where season 1 ended. LuPone also revealed that she initially wanted a second season but accepted Schaeffer’s decision after talking with her .
Brad Winderbaum’s comments about wanting to do a second season reflect Marvel’s interest in continuing the successful franchise, but on their own terms and timeline. The executive made it clear they want “the right idea” before moving forward .
The most likely outcome is that Agatha All Along will not have a traditional season 2, but the characters from the show will appear in other MCU projects. This is exactly what happened with WandaVision characters, who moved into movies like Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness and other series.
Where Agatha And Billy Could Appear Next
Even if Agatha All Along does not return for a second season, the characters introduced in the show have clear paths forward in the MCU. Joe Locke’s character Billy Maximoff, also known as Wiccan in the comics, is expected to play a larger role in future stories .
One possibility is the character appearing in the upcoming Vision Quest series, which focuses on Paul Bettany’s White Vision. Bettany recently revealed that he is preparing for his role by watching Agatha All Along, hinting that the two shows are connected. This makes sense given that Billy is Vision and Wanda Maximoff’s son in the comics .
Another potential appearance could be in the Avengers: Doomsday or Secret Wars movies. With the multiverse saga continuing, characters like Agatha and Billy could easily show up in these massive crossover events .
Aubrey Plaza’s character Rio Vidal, who played Death in the series, also has potential to return. The show confirmed that Rio and Agatha “were married, in some witchy way,” adding depth to their relationship that could be explored in future projects .
Fan Reactions To The Mixed Updates
The conflicting news about Agatha All Along season 2 has generated significant discussion among Marvel fans. When LuPone first said there would be no second season, many fans expressed disappointment on social media. But Winderbaum’s later comments gave those same fans renewed hope .
Some fans have pointed out that even if the show does not continue, Agatha Harkness remains one of the most popular new MCU characters in recent years. Her unique personality and Hahn’s performance made the character a standout, making it likely Marvel will find ways to bring her back .
Fan theories continue to circulate about what a second season could explore, including the search for Billy’s twin brother Tommy Maximoff, which was hinted at in the season finale. Others want to see more of Agatha and Rio’s complicated history .
Also Read:
What To Expect Going Forward
For now, the official status of Agatha All Along season 2 remains unconfirmed. Marvel has not made any formal announcement about renewing or canceling the series. The most accurate way to understand the situation is:
- Patti LuPone believes there will not be a second season based on what showrunner Jac Schaeffer told the cast
- Brad Winderbaum says Marvel wants to do a second season but only with the right creative approach
- Jac Schaeffer prefers limited series and may not return as showrunner for a second season
- Kathryn Hahn expects to play Agatha again but does not know in what format
The safe bet is that Agatha Harkness will return to screens, but it may not be in a show called Agatha All Along season 2. She could appear in projects like Vision Quest, Avengers movies, or even a completely new series focused on the magical side of the MCU.
For fans who want to revisit the first season, all nine episodes of Agatha All Along are currently streaming on Disney+ in the US, UK, Canada, Australia, India, and globally on the platform.
Stay tuned to VvipTimes for more updates on your favorite Marvel shows and characters as new information becomes available.
