The Hulu legal drama All’s Fair is officially coming back for a second season after a record-breaking debut, but one familiar face will not be part of the new episodes. Judith Light has confirmed that her character, the vibrant client Sheila Baskin, will not be returning for the show’s next chapter.
During an appearance at TheWrap Power Women Summit, Light addressed her future on the show. She explained that she was always a guest star for the first season and is not part of the plans for season two. She expressed strong support and happiness for the main cast, which includes stars like Niecy Nash-Betts, Naomi Watts, Kim Kardashian, Glenn Close, and Sarah Paulson, along with creator Ryan Murphy.
Light played Sheila Baskin, a wealthy and interesting client of the all-female law firm, appearing in the first two episodes of the series. While she will not be back, the core group of lawyers is expected to return for more high-stakes divorce drama.
The Unexpected Hit: How All’s Fair Earned a Season 2
Despite facing harsh criticism from professional reviewers, All’s Fair became a major viewership success for Hulu. The series premiered on November 4, 2025, with its first three episodes. Within just three days, it attracted approximately 3.2 million views globally, making it Hulu’s biggest scripted series debut in three years. This strong audience response led Hulu to announce the season two renewal on November 24, 2025.
The show’s performance highlights a significant divide between critics and viewers. On the review site Rotten Tomatoes, the series holds a critic score of only 3%, based on 30 reviews. One critic from The Guardian gave the show zero stars, calling it astonishingly bad television. However, the audience score on the same site tells a different story, sitting at a much higher 66%. This disconnect between critical panning and popular appeal is a key reason the show will continue.
Inside the World of All’s Fair
The series was created by Ryan Murphy and follows Allura Grant, a successful divorce lawyer played by Kim Kardashian. Allura co-owns an all-female law firm in Los Angeles with her colleagues, navigating glamorous clients, personal conflicts, and power struggles. The show’s synopsis describes it as a story about women who “don’t just play the game—they change it”.
Ryan Murphy described the series as “a show about women getting the last word,” adding that it is meant to bring high fashion back to television in a major way. This focus on style is a signature element, with the costume design by Lou Eyrich receiving specific praise from Judith Light, who said the clothing and shoes were essential to building her character.
The Star-Studded Cast Moving Forward
With season two confirmed, attention turns to who will be back in the courtroom. While Hulu has not released an official cast list, it is highly likely that the main attorneys will return to reprise their roles. This group includes:
- Kim Kardashian as Allura Grant
- Naomi Watts as Liberty Ronson
- Sarah Paulson as Carrington “Carr” Lane
- Niecy Nash-Betts as Emerald Greene
- Teyana Taylor as Milan
- Glenn Close as Dina Standish
The cast has shown clear enthusiasm for continuing the project. Glenn Close celebrated the renewal news on Instagram, writing, “Batten down the hatches, we’re coming BACK”. Sarah Paulson responded to the post with, “YES QUEENS 🔥🔥”.
The actors have also spoken about the close bond they formed while filming. Niecy Nash-Betts noted that unlike typical coworkers, the cast actively wanted to spend time together off-set, asking about weekend plans and dinners. Kim Kardashian shared that her co-stars even helped her study for the bar exam while she was filming, quizzing her with flashcards.
Also Read:
What’s Next for All’s Fair Season 2?
Details about the upcoming season are still emerging. Reports indicate that creator Ryan Murphy has already begun writing the second season. While a specific release date has not been set, one report suggests that production is scheduled to begin in spring 2026.
The first season is currently streaming on Hulu, with the two-part finale set to be released on December 9, 2025. The continuation of the series proves that in the world of streaming, strong audience numbers can sometimes speak louder than critical reviews.
Also Read: Ilya Rozanov’s Age in Heated Rivalry: Character and Actor Details Explained
