Benedict Bridgerton finally took center stage in Season 4 Part 1, but his romantic proposal to Sophie Baek landed with a thud rather than a swoon. The eldest Bridgerton brother still looking for love shocked viewers by asking the woman he claims to consume his thoughts to become his mistress instead of his wife. As fans digest the dramatic cliffhanger, the big question floating around Reddit and social media is whether Benedict can fix this mess when the season returns.
The moment arrived in Episode 4 after weeks of building tension between Benedict and Sophie. He found her on the staircase, confessed she consumes him, and said she deserves better. Then came the words that made audiences gasp for all the wrong reasons. “Sophie, be my mistress.” Sophie walked away in silence, leaving Benedict alone and confused as the screen faded to black .
Fans immediately flooded social media with their reactions. One viewer on X wrote, “Benedict Bridgerton I love you but you are SO STUPIDDDD for asking Sophie to be your MISTRESS” . Another fan pointed out a heartbreaking detail, noting that the moment Sophie finally called him “Benedict” instead of “Mr. Bridgerton” happened right before he crushed her with his offer .
Why Benedict Made That Offer in the First Place
Showrunner Jess Brownell explained the thinking behind Benedict’s controversial proposal. She told Variety that the staircase scene was meant to show the reality of class divisions during the Regency era. For a gentleman and a housemaid to be together in that time, asking someone to be a mistress was considered the only option .
Brownell acknowledged why modern viewers find it offensive. “For a modern audience, it seems like a real slap in the face, but the fact of the matter is that it was incredibly common,” she said. She also made clear that Sophie’s reaction is completely justified. “She wanted to believe that Benedict saw her for more than her station. So she has a real right to be very pissed” .
Luke Thompson, who plays Benedict, admitted the scene surprised him when he first read the script. He told Entertainment Weekly that it was fun to play with audience expectations. “We all do things that are out of character sometimes and, often, the things that we do that are out of character are the things that actually say the most about us,” Thompson explained .
Thompson also offered insight into Benedict’s mindset. He believes his character isn’t acting out of cruelty but rather desperation. Benedict thinks he can create a situation that works for both of them without fully understanding how his offer diminishes Sophie’s worth .
Yerin Ha, who plays Sophie, had a much stronger reaction to the scene. When asked about it, she said simply, “Yeah, I was fuming” .
Reddit Fans Weigh In on Benedict’s Fate
The Reddit community has been buzzing with theories about whether Benedict can recover from this mistake. Many fans point out that the show has set up a clear path for redemption, even if the character doesn’t see it yet.
Several Redditors noted that Benedict’s offer comes from a place of insecurity rather than malice. One theory suggests that meeting Sophie will actually help Benedict rediscover his passion for art, which he abandoned after learning Anthony bought his way into art school. A fan wrote that Sophie will become his muse, and when he finds his happy ending, his talent will be unleashed in a fulfilling way .
Another Reddit user highlighted that the show has a chance to explore Benedict beyond his usual carefree attitude. With Anthony away in India, Benedict is serving as acting Viscount, which gives writers room to show his compassionate and decisive side before everything goes wrong with Sophie .
However, not all Reddit feedback has been forgiving. Some viewers expressed frustration with the pacing of the season and Benedict’s slowness in recognizing Sophie. One user commented, “How on earth does Benedict not realize who she is?” referring to the masquerade ball where they first met .
Another Redditor wrote, “The insecurity that comes from being an artist and showing off your work, it can be scary. When Benedict finds his happy ending, his talent will be unleashed and it will be so fulfilling. And then you see he starts painting Sophie how she is with no mask. The true love of his life” .
What the Trailers Reveal About Benedict’s Journey
The preview for Part 2 offers hope that Benedict will realize his mistake. In one scene, he confides in Will Mondrich, saying, “There is a woman. She is not a person of any rank, and I have upset her.” Will responds with wisdom that seems designed to shake Benedict awake: “No matter her rank, no woman truly desires to be hidden” .
Violet Bridgerton also has a serious conversation with her son in the trailer. She asks him directly, “Will you sacrifice your family? Whatever you choose, you must live with it forever. We all will.” Given Violet’s strong belief in love over social conventions, her words suggest she’s pushing Benedict to follow his heart but also warning him about the lasting consequences of his choices .
The trailer shows Sophie planning to leave Bridgerton House, telling Violet her decision isn’t about “anyone” in the household. But Violet clearly senses there’s more to the story and seems determined to uncover the truth .
How the Show Compares to the Book
Fans who have read Julia Quinn’s novel An Offer from a Gentleman noticed differences in how the mistress proposal plays out. In the book, Benedict asks Sophie to come back to London with him after they share a kiss by the lake. He doesn’t actually use the word “mistress” until Sophie herself points out that’s what he’s asking for. While still a loaded offer, it comes across as less jarring than the on-screen version where Benedict states it directly .
Book Benedict also keeps his artistic interests private until Sophie discovers his work, including a sketch of her, and assures him of his talent. This differs from the show, where Benedict openly pursued art school before having his confidence shattered .
The show has taken other liberties as well. Sophie’s last name changed from Beckett in the books to Baek in the series, reflecting Yerin Ha’s Korean heritage. Showrunner Jess Brownell personally asked Ha if there were Korean surnames starting with B, a detail that made the actress feel seen and empowered on the massive production .
Fan Frustrations Beyond the Mistress Offer
Some viewers have expressed broader concerns about Season 4 beyond Benedict’s proposal. Critics point out that Netflix hasn’t given the Netflix-only audience enough reason to be invested in Benedict as a lead. Across three previous seasons, he often existed on the narrative sidelines, charming but rarely central to the main action .
One review described the season as feeling “disconnected” from the momentum of Season 3. Several fans on Reddit noted that the chemistry between Benedict and Sophie isn’t reaching the level of previous couples like Anthony and Kate. One user commented, “Chemistry isn’t S2 level to me but it’s not non-existent. Pacing was a bit strange, I couldn’t really tell how much time was supposed to be passing” .
Another recurring complaint involves Benedict’s failure to recognize Sophie after the masquerade. Viewers find it hard to believe he can’t identify someone whose face was barely hidden, leading to moments that feel like narrative stalling rather than romantic tension .
Also Read:
What Needs to Happen in Part 2
Brownell has confirmed that Sophie will take space when Part 2 premieres, but she also teased that “the thirst will get them back together pretty quickly” . This suggests fans won’t have to wait long for Benedict to start his redemption arc.
The showrunner also emphasized that the reaction to Benedict’s offer is exactly what the writers intended. She said Sophie’s outrage is “correct” and that Benedict’s lack of understanding about how his words would land is something the show will “bring him up on in the back half” .
Several fan theories suggest Benedict will need to do more than simply apologize. He may have to actively choose Sophie over his family’s expectations and social standing. One Reddit user predicted that Benedict will feel more isolated from his brothers than ever, with both Anthony and Colin now husbands and fathers, which could either push him toward Sophie or create more obstacles .
The expanded focus on class differences this season may also play into Benedict’s redemption. By highlighting the lives of household staff alongside the Ton, the show has set up a world where Benedict must truly understand Sophie’s position rather than just offering her a hidden place within his .
Bridgerton Season 4 Part 2 arrives on Netflix February 26. Until then, fans can only speculate whether Benedict will rise to the occasion or remain the brother who just couldn’t figure out what the woman he loved actually needed to hear.
Stay connected with VvipTimes for the latest entertainment news, cast interviews, and streaming guides for all the biggest series dominating conversations right now.
