High Potential Season 2 Episode 5 Cast Guide: Who Played Who in “Content Warning”?

Kaitlin Olson in High Potential

(

)

The latest episode of ABC‘s hit crime drama, High Potential, delivered a case ripped from the headlines, taking Morgan and Karadec into the chaotic world of online influencers. “Content Warning,” which aired on October 14, 2025, also introduced a new commanding officer and moved a key personal mystery forward. For fans keeping track of who’s who in the LAPD’s Major Crimes unit, here is a breakdown of the cast and characters from the episode.

The Core Cast Returning for Season 2

The entire main team is back for the second season, continuing the dynamics that have become a hallmark of the show.

Kaitlin Olson returns as Morgan Gillory, the brilliant single mother and civilian consultant whose unconventional problem-solving skills continue to be an asset to the LAPD. In this episode, her sharp mind is focused on a social media-related homicide while she also deals with personal pressures.

Daniel Sunjata reprises his role as Detective Adam Karadec, the by-the-book partner who provides a steady balance to Morgan’s intuitive leaps. His methodical approach to investigation is a crucial counterpoint as they navigate the flashy world of influencer culture.

The rest of the tight-knit squad includes:

  • Judy Reyes as Lieutenant Selena Soto, the head of the Major Crimes Division who finds her authority adjusting with new leadership.
  • Deniz Akdeniz as Lev “Oz” ร–zdil, an investigator known for his positive attitude.
  • Javicia Leslie as Daphne Forrester, a dedicated and competitive investigator.
  • Amirah J as Ava Gillory, Morgan’s teenage daughter who becomes more actively involved in searching for her missing father.
  • Matthew Lamb as Elliot Radovic, Morgan’s son.

A New Face in the Precinct

A significant change in the unit’s dynamics comes with the arrival of a new character, marking a major casting addition for the season.

Steve Howey joins the cast as the new Captain Nick Wagner. He is described as a savvy political animal with effortless charm, who knows how to wear an expensive suit. Captain Wagner has a disruptor’s tenacity and, much like Morgan, enjoys thinking outside the box. He inserts himself into the middle of the action, wanting to get to know the team’s operations intimately. His arrival immediately causes shifts, notably relocating Selena Soto from her own office and taking a particular interest in Morgan’s unique role within the department.

Recurring Characters and Guest Stars

The episode also features several recurring characters who play key roles in the ongoing serialized stories.

Taran Killam appears as Ludo Radovic, Morgan’s second ex-husband, who acts as a “manny” for their children.

Mekhi Phifer has a recurring role in Season 2 as Arthur Ellis, an old friend of Morgan’s missing first husband, Roman. In “Content Warning,” Morgan confronts him, seeking answers about Roman’s disappearance.

The case-of-the-week featured its own set of guest characters involved in the influencer content house homicide. The victim was Tori Nolan, an investigative journalist living undercover in the content house. Key suspects and figures in the investigation included:

  • Phineas, the leader of the content house, who was an initial suspect.
  • Bobby Romano, a protein powder brand owner and Tori’s college ex-nemesis, who also ends up dead.
  • Gavin Tillman, a halfway house operator ultimately revealed to be the culprit, running a drug pipeline that contaminated the protein powder.

The Major Plotlines of “Content Warning”

The episode wove together two major storylines, balancing a self-contained case with ongoing character arcs.

The Influencer House Homicide

The central case began when a social media stunt turned deadly, leading Morgan and Karadec to investigate a content house filled with influencers. Their investigation into the death of Tori Nolan revealed she was digging into a protein powder brand with a dangerous, contaminated ingredient list. The trail ultimately led them to Gavin Tillman, who was using his halfway house as a front for a drug operation.

Ava’s Search and a New Captain

Meanwhile, the episode advanced two significant personal plots. Morgan’s daughter, Ava, tired of waiting for answers about her father, took matters into her own hands. Her actions led to a confrontation and a serious conversation with Morgan about the dangers of her investigation.

Simultaneously, the entire team had to adjust to the new management style of Captain Nick Wagner. His hands-on approach and specific interest in Morgan’s methods created an undercurrent of tension, with Morgan sensing he had hidden agendas.

The episode ended with a major development in the long-running mystery of Roman’s disappearance, as Morgan secured his old backpack, suggesting that its contents could soon reveal critical secrets.

Also Read: Who Is Morgan Kissing In High Potential Season 2? Kaitlin Olson Confirms A โ€œBig Makeout Sceneโ€