Russell Crowe Criticizes Gladiator II for Missing Maximus’s ‘Moral Core’

Russell Crowe has explained why he believes the 2024 sequel Gladiator II missed the point of the original movie. The actor, who won an Oscar for playing Maximus in the 2000 classic, said the new film fails to understand that the first movie’s success was built on its main character’s strong morals, not just its action. Crowe did not appear in the sequel and took issue with a key plot point involving his character’s legacy.

Crowe’s Core Criticism of the Sequel

In an interview with Australian radio station Triple J, Crowe shared his direct thoughts on the sequel. He did not name the film but made his target clear. His central argument is that the new creative team misunderstood what made the original Gladiator connect with audiences.

“I think the recent sequel that… we don’t have to name out loud is a really unfortunate example of even the people in that engine room not actually understanding what made the first one special,” Crowe said. “It wasn’t the pomp. It wasn’t the circumstance. It wasn’t the action. It was the moral core.”

Crowe stated that protecting this “moral core” for his character, Maximus, was a constant effort during the making of the first film. He recalled frequently pushing back against suggestions from filmmakers that he felt would weaken the character’s integrity.

The ‘Daily Fight’ to Protect Maximus’s Character

The actor revealed that during the production of the 2000 film, he often disagreed with directors and writers over how to portray Maximus. He described a persistent effort to keep the character focused on his purpose: avenging his murdered family.

“The thing is, there was a daily fight on that set. It was a daily fight to keep that moral core of the character,” Crowe explained. “The amount of times they suggested s** scenes and stuff like that for Maximus, it’s like – you’re taking away his power.”

For Crowe, Maximus’s strength came from his singular, honorable goal. The character’s journey begins after his wife and son are killed, and his entire motivation is to gain vengeance and then reunite with them in the afterlife. Crowe felt that adding other romantic relationships or distractions betrayed this core idea.

Why the Sequel’s Plot Twist Felt ‘Crazy’

Crowe’s strongest objection is to a major reveal in Gladiator II. The sequel follows Lucius (Paul Mescal), who is revealed to be the secret son of Maximus and Lucilla (Connie Nielsen), the sister of the original film’s villain, Commodus. To Crowe, this retcons Maximus’s established backstory in a damaging way.

The original film portrays Maximus as a deeply loyal husband grieving his wife. The sequel’s plot suggests he was unfaithful while married. Crowe expressed disbelief at this narrative choice.

“So you’re saying at the same time he had this relationship with his wife, he was f***ing this other girl? What are you talking about? It’s crazy,” Crowe said of the plot line.

Crowe even noted that after the sequel’s release, fans confronted him about this story change. He said people, especially women in Europe, would approach him at restaurants to question the decision, to which he would reply, “Hey, it wasn’t me! I didn’t do it!”.

Comparing the Legacy of Two Films

The difference in how the two films were received highlights Crowe’s point for some observers. The original Gladiator was a major critical and awards success. It won five Academy Awards in 2001, including Best Picture and Best Actor for Crowe.

Gladiator II, released in November 2024, featured a new star in Paul Mescal alongside major actors like Denzel Washington and Pedro Pascal. While it earned over $462 million globally, its awards recognition was limited to a single Oscar nomination for Best Costume Design. Critics were mixed, with some reviews saying it relied too much on spectacle and repeated the original’s plot without capturing its emotional depth.

Screenwriter David Scarpa previously acknowledged the challenge of making a sequel to such a beloved film, noting the team wanted continuity but not to simply repeat the first movie.

Also Read: The Hunting Party Season 2: Release Date, New Guest Cast and Where to Stream

---