The gripping Peacock miniseries All Her Fault, starring Sarah Snook, concluded with a dramatic finale that wrapped up its central mystery, leaving viewers to wonder if the story will continue. The show, which follows a mother’s desperate search for her kidnapped son, was conceived as a limited series, and as of late November 2025, Peacock has not announced a second season.
The Official Stance on a New Season
All Her Fault was designed and pitched as a limited series with a self-contained, eight-episode narrative. The show fully adapted Andrea Mara’s source novel, leaving no remaining book material for a sequel. Creator and showrunner Megan Gallagher has expressed personal interest in participating in a second season, even suggesting it could be reimagined with new storylines or an anthology format. However, she has confirmed that no official renewal decision has been made.
Sarah Snook told The Hollywood Reporter that the show’s attractiveness is that it’s a limited series, but pondered, “How does Milo grow up in this new dynamic? When does he learn the information about his past?”
The Story Wrapped Up in Season 1
A significant reason a second season is uncertain is that the first season’s story reached a definitive conclusion. The mystery of who took Milo and why was completely resolved. The finale revealed that the nanny, Carrie Finch, was actually the biological mother of the child, and that Sarah Snook’s character, Marissa, had been unknowingly raising him after her husband switched the infants years before.
Several major characters, including Peter and Carrie, died in the finale. This means a direct continuation of the same story would require a significant reimagining, as key players are no longer part of the narrative.
Strong Viewership Offers Hope
Despite the narrative closure, the show’s performance offers a compelling reason for Peacock to consider more content. In its first week, All Her Fault was a major success for Peacock, topping the Luminate streaming charts with 33.6 million hours watched. This strong debut demonstrates significant audience interest, which is a key factor networks consider for renewal. The final decision will likely depend on how the show performs in streaming metrics over the coming weeks.
What a Potential Season 2 Could Look Like
If the show does return, it would not be a direct continuation. Instead, creator Megan Gallagher is open to an anthology format. This could mean a new season set in the same universe but featuring a different cast of characters and a new mystery, similar to how shows like Big Little Lies eventually expanded. Such a format could potentially bring back actors like Dakota Fanning or Michael Peña in new roles.
Also Read:
Hazbin Hotel Season 3 Confirmed: Cast, Plot Details, and Release Window
Hazbin Hotel Season 2 Finale: Episodes 7 and 8 Release Guide
To My Shore: Your Complete Guide to the New Chinese BL Drama
Dynamite Kiss Episode Schedule: Your Complete Guide to New Episode Releases
Dear X Episode Schedule: Your Guide to New Episode Releases
Hwang In-youp and Kim Yoo-jung’s On-Screen Chemistry Sparks Fan Demand for New Drama
Credits: Variety
