After weeks of showing us the non-stop chaos of influencer life, I Love LA slowed things down in its fifth episode for a dinner party that ended up revealing more about its characters than any viral video ever could. The episode, which aired on HBO and HBO Max on Sunday, November 30, 2025, presented a seemingly simple evening that forced Maia to confront her ambitions, her relationship, and what she truly wants from her life in Los Angeles.
Titled “They Can’t All Be Jeremys,” the hour centered on a nerve-wracking dinner invitation. Maia and her steady boyfriend, Dylan, are asked to the Los Feliz home of Maia’s boss, Alyssa, and her husband, Jeremy. What starts as a professional coup for Maia—a chance to impress her powerful manager outside the office—slowly unravels into an awkward, funny, and cringe-inducing look at a “successful” life that might not be so successful after all.
“Maia’s now angling for becoming Alyssa’s go-to in more ways than one. Enlisting Dylan into her charm offensive is a risky step, but if she wants to become more of a power player at work, it is a crucial one,” one review noted.
The Picture-Perfect Evening That Wasn’t
From the moment Maia and Dylan arrive at Alyssa’s stylish home, the cracks in the facade are visible. Maia is dressed to impress, wearing perfume and hoping to charm her way further into Alyssa’s good graces. Dylan, a schoolteacher with a more grounded outlook, is immediately out of his element, accidentally bringing up his current reading—a book about Nazi Germany—to light dinner conversation.
The dinner’s host, Jeremy, played by Ben Feldman, quickly proves to be the source of the episode’s title. He is portrayed as a pompous and unpleasant man who seems to resent his wife’s success. He complains that Maia’s voice and perfume are triggering a migraine and abruptly leaves the table, forcing Dylan to step up and cook the promised steak dinner himself.
Left alone with a increasingly drunk Alyssa, Maia gets a crash course in marital disillusionment. Alyssa complains about Jeremy’s lost work ethic and drinks wine while critiquing Dylan’s perfectly cooked steak. The supposed “power couple” life Maia admires is exposed as a depressing performance.
The most shocking revelation comes when Maia slips away to the bathroom. Through a glass door, she accidentally sees Jeremy in another room, masturbating to porn, completely unaware he can be seen. This jarring moment shatters any remaining illusion of the perfect life Alyssa has built.
Charlie Finds an Unlikely New Crowd
While Maia navigates the dinner party disaster, her friend Charlie finds himself in a social situation that is foreign to him in a different way. After successfully landing a styling gig with Lukas, a wholesome Christian TikTok singer, Charlie is invited to hang out with Lukas and his group of friends.
These “Accountability Bros,” as one recap called them, operate on a system of positive support, texting each other for help when tempted to sin. Charlie, whose friendships are built on sarcasm and witty insults, is completely baffled by their genuine kindness. When he gets sick in front of them after a night out, he braces for mockery, but instead receives only concern.
This experience begins to change Charlie. He tries out this new, kinder way of communicating, even telling Alani he loves her instead of a cutting remark. However, this subplot takes a tragic turn. At the end of the episode, a news alert reveals that Lukas has died in an ATV accident, leaving Charlie’s new path forward suddenly cut short.
Tallulah and Alani’s Driving Lesson
The episode’s third storyline provided some lighter comedy. With Maia having secured a $30,000 sponsorship deal with Kia for Tallulah, the influencer realizes she needs to remember how to drive for the promotional content.
She turns to Alani for a lesson. Alani’s advice is classic Los Angeles nonchalance, suggesting Tallulah just shrug off any potential accidents as part of city living. The driving lesson is short-lived, but the car ride is productive in another way. Tallulah helps Alani navigate her flirtation with a new guy, Garrett, by ghostwriting perfectly aloof texts that successfully grab his attention.
Also Read:
A Relationship at a Crossroads
The fallout from the dinner party continues when Maia and Dylan return home. Dylan, having seen the emptiness behind Alyssa’s luxurious life, articulates his own life philosophy clearly: “we work to live”. For Maia, who is increasingly driven by professional ambition and impressed by the trappings of success, this is a direct challenge.
The episode closes on Maia visibly troubled, chewing her fingernail in her kitchen as she replays Alyssa’s condescending comments and looks at her dependable boyfriend in a new light. The evening did not go as planned. Instead of securing her status as Alyssa’s favorite, she witnessed the hollowness of that goal and is now questioning if her life with Dylan is part of the future she wants.
The fifth episode of I Love LA moved the season’s central tension into sharp focus. It asks what success really costs and whether the drive to achieve it is worth sacrificing genuine, if less glamorous, connections.
Also Read: Alien: Earth Season 2 Will Avoid The Unfinished Fate of Ridley Scott’s Prequel Movies
