My Life with the Walter Boys returned for its second season on August 28, 2025, bringing back the beloved characters and introducing new faces to the story. The Netflix series follows Jackie Howard, a teenager who moves to a Colorado ranch after losing her family. She lives with the Walter family, which includes many boys. The show explores her relationships, grief, and journey to find belonging.
The cast includes both returning actors and new additions. This guide provides a detailed look at the stars behind the characters and their roles in the latest season.
Main Cast and Returning Characters
Nikki Rodriguez plays Jackie Howard, the central character. Jackie is a 16-year-old from Manhattan who moves to Colorado after her parents die. She struggles to fit into the large Walter family and finds herself torn between two brothers. Rodriguez previously appeared in Netflix’s On My Block as Vero. She is 22 years old but plays a younger character .
Noah LaLonde portrays Cole Walter, the brooding and mysterious older brother. Cole was a football star whose career ended due to an injury. He is one of the brothers in the love triangle with Jackie. LaLonde is 27 years old and has appeared in shows like Criminal Minds. He grew up playing hockey, which helped him understand Cole’s athletic background .
Ashby Gentry plays Alex Walter, the younger, more bookish brother. Alex is kind and reliable, but season 2 shows a changed version of him. He becomes more confident and involved in rodeo riding. Gentry is 26 years old and has a background in theater. He also appeared in Are You Afraid of the Dark? .
Sarah Rafferty plays Katherine Walter, the matriarch of the Walter family. She is a veterinarian and Jackie’s guardian. Rafferty is 52 years old and is best known for her role as Donna Paulsen in Suits. She has also appeared in Chicago Med and Grey’s Anatomy .
Marc Blucas plays George Walter, the family patriarch. He manages the ranch and faces financial challenges. Blucas is 53 years old and is known for his role in Buffy the Vampire Slayer. He also appeared in Narcos Mexico and Knight and Day .
Other returning cast members include Johnny Link as Will Walter, the eldest son who is hard of hearing; Corey Fogelmanis as Nathan Walter, the musical and openly gay brother; Connor Stanhope as Danny Walter, Cole’s twin who loves theater; Zoë Soul as Hayley, Will’s wife; and Jaylan Evans as Skylar, Nathan’s boyfriend and Jackie’s friend .
New Cast Members in Season 2
Season 2 introduces several new characters and actors. Natalie Sharp joins as B. Hartford, a champion rodeo rider. She is confident and skilled in a male-dominated sport. Sharp has previously appeared in Wilderness and the Beverly Hills, 90210 reboot BH90210 .
Carson MacCormac plays Zach, a handsome and charismatic senior who shows interest in Nathan. MacCormac has been in Shazam! Fury of the Gods and Locke & Key .
Riele Downs plays Maria, a new classmate of Alex’s. Downs has been acting for nearly two decades and is known for her voice work in Henry Danger Motion Comic and The Adventures of Kid Danger .
Jake Manley appears as Wylder Holt, a bronc rider. Manley has had roles in The Order and other TV series. Janet Kidder plays Joanne Wagner, Grace’s mother and a friend of Katherine’s. Kidder has been in Star Trek: Discovery and The Man in the High Castle .
Supporting Cast and Family Members
The Walter family includes many children and extended relatives. Dean Petriw plays Jordan Walter, the family filmmaker. Alix West Lefler plays Parker Walter, the only daughter in the family. Lennix James plays Benny Walter, the youngest son. Isaac Arellanes and Myles Perez play Isaac and Lee Garcia, cousins who live with the Walters .
Other supporting characters include Alisha Newton as Erin, Cole’s ex-girlfriend; Ellie O’Brien as Grace, Jackie’s friend; Mya Lowe as Kiley, Alex’s friend; and Kolton Stewart as Dylan, Cole’s friend .
Character Arcs and Season 2 Developments
In season 2, Jackie returns to Silver Falls after spending the summer in New York. She tries to make amends with Alex and set boundaries with Cole. However, Alex has changed significantly after attending rodeo camp. He becomes more popular and confident, which creates tension .
“Season 1 Alex is no more. Old Alex is pretty much gone and I don’t know if he’s coming back. Sweet, innocent, lover, poetic no more. You’re getting rodeo, popular, attractive,” Ashby Gentry told Teen Vogue .
Cole takes on a new role as an assistant coach for the football team. This helps him find purpose after his injury. However, he still struggles with his feelings for Jackie. The love triangle remains a central focus of the season .
New characters like B. Hartford and Zach add fresh dynamics to the story. B. Hartford becomes a love interest for Alex, while Zach connects with Nathan. These relationships introduce new conflicts and opportunities for character growth .
Production and Background
The series is based on the novel by Ali Novak. However, season 2 is an original story not directly taken from the book. The author released a sequel novel in April 2025, but the show has taken a different direction .
Filming for season 2 took place in Calgary, Canada. Jason Priestley, known for Beverly Hills, 90210, directed several episodes. The cast has grown closer over time, which helped them perform with more confidence .
“Everybody was pretty nervous in that first season, but the way the public responded gave all of them a little boost of confidence, which is important when you’re an actor,” Priestley said .
The season consists of 10 episodes, all released on August 28, 2025. Ahead of the season 2 premiere, Netflix renewed the series for a third season, which is expected to release in 2026 .
Audience Reception and Impact
The first season was a hit with audiences, leading to a quick renewal. Fans appreciated the show’s handling of themes like grief, friendship, and identity. The love triangle between Jackie, Alex, and Cole has been a major talking point .
Some viewers criticized certain aspects, such as Jackie’s lack of financial support for the Walter family despite her inheritance. Others found the acting or pacing inconsistent. However, many praised the performances of Rodriguez, LaLonde, and Gentry .
The show has been compared to other teen dramas like The Summer I Turned Pretty. Despite similarities, it has carved out its own identity with a focus on family dynamics and rural life .
Credits: Teen Vogue, Cosmopolitan, Netflix Tudum
