Shane Gillis has spoken about the backlash to his October 10 Saturday Night Live monologue for the first time, telling Joe Rogan that he warned the show his set was a “solid C-minus” but promised it would not cause problems. The comedian also made clear that, personally, he has no issue with how women dress at the gym — the exact topic that set off a month of criticism.
Gillis made the comments on the November 13 episode of The Joe Rogan Experience, which was released two days before the first wave of news coverage on November 14. The interview covered the joke itself, the reaction from celebrities and former SNL cast members, and how Gillis handled the fallout on social media.
What Gillis Said He Told SNL Before the Show
A co-host on Rogan’s podcast noted that Gillis had performed the same gym material at New York City’s Comedy Cellar the week before the SNL broadcast and suggested the show had approved it. Gillis pushed back on that idea. He explained that SNL does not pre-approve monologue material for comedians and that he wrote and delivered the set without needing sign-off.
“Not to defend SNL, they don’t approve it. I mean, they could shut it down. They could, but you don’t write your set and give it to them. Unless you’re not a comedian.”
Gillis said SNL staff did ask him what to expect from the monologue ahead of the live show. His answer was blunt.
“The funniest part was, they were like, ‘What’s going on with the monologue?’ And I was like, ‘It’s not great, but I don’t say anything bad.’ The whole time, I was like, ‘Fellas, I’m giving you a solid C minus of a monologue, but I promise there’s no controversy. I’m calling myself fat for fucking 10 minutes. That’s it.’”
The monologue aired during SNL‘s 52nd season, with Rosalía as the musical guest. It was Gillis’ third time hosting the show. He first hosted in February 2024 and returned in March 2025.
The Gym Joke That Started the Backlash
The line that drew the most attention came when Gillis talked about not having been to a gym in a long time. He said he did not realize women now “dress like whores” to work out. He then described the shorts in detail, including the wrinkles and the bright colors, and joked that he was probably in the background of multiple TikToks filmed by women exercising.
“I haven’t been to the gym in so long, I didn’t know women just dress like whores now? Look, I’m sorry, there’s no other way to describe it. Have you seen it? I’ve seen it. The shorts. Have you seen the shorts?”
The joke drew audible groans from parts of the studio audience, according to Complex, which also noted that a later punchline about being “either gay or Hitler” received a muted response. The monologue also included jokes about his weight, muscular gay men at the gym, and his sisters.
‘A Lot to Do With the Climate’
Gillis told Rogan he was surprised by how much the joke travelled. He said the response “obviously had a lot to do with the climate” at the time of the episode’s release.
Rogan agreed with that view and defended the joke as simple comedy.
“It’s just a fun thing to say and it’s funny. That’s it. And this is a weird time where everyone’s just looking to get upset.”
Gillis also said he handled the social media reaction differently this time compared to his 2019 firing from SNL. After the 2019 incident, he kept his accounts and read what people were saying. This time, he deleted everything immediately.
‘For the Record, Don’t Have a Problem With It’
The most direct statement from Gillis about the joke’s subject came near the end of the podcast discussion. He clarified that he does not actually have a problem with women’s gym clothing.
“For the record, [I] don’t have a problem with it.”
Rogan and the other comedians on the episode, including Mark Normand and Ari Shaffir, went on to agree that the public reaction was overblown.
The Celebrities Who Pushed Back
The backlash was not limited to social media users. Several high-profile figures spoke out against the joke in the days after the episode aired.
Dan Levy, the Schitt’s Creek star and creator, posted an Instagram video calling the joke misogynistic and saying he was “speechless” that it made it to air.
“Women wearing short shorts at the gym does not make them whores, it makes the men calling them whores misogynists. There’s a difference there.”
Ego Nwodim, a former SNL cast member, responded with a gym mirror selfie and the caption “whore reporting for duty.” Cecily Strong, another SNL alum, also mocked the joke on Instagram.
Singer Maren Morris posted a video giving the middle finger with the caption “me being a wh0re at the gym.” Flavor Flav praised Levy’s response as “important allyship.” Maggie Baird, the mother of Billie Eilish and Finneas, called the joke “actually dangerous for women to promote.” Jewel and Kristin Chenoweth also showed support for Levy’s criticism.
SNL UK also took a shot at Gillis. During a Weekend Update segment, co-host Ania Magliano called him a “stupid f—ing c—” in a joke that aired uncensored in the U.K.
Defenders and the Ratings
Not everyone criticised the monologue. David Spade, Dana Carvey, and Jimmy Carr came to Gillis’ defence. Carvey said he “didn’t understand the kerfuffle.”
The controversy did not hurt viewership. Nielsen Live+Same Day data showed the October 10 episode averaged 4.4 million total viewers and 1.1 million viewers in the key 18-49 demographic. That was up 1 percent in total viewers and 4 percent in the demo from the previous week, and up 4 percent and 15 percent respectively from the third episode of the previous season. It was Gillis’ highest-rated hosting episode to date.
Kenan Thompson Says the Backlash ‘Overshadowed’ the Episode
Longtime SNL cast member Kenan Thompson weighed in on October 21 at the Axios Media Trends Live summit. He said he does not know Gillis to be a mean person, but that a conversation would be needed if Gillis hosts again.
“If he were to come back [to ‘SNL’], I’m sure we would have a conversation of like, ‘How do you think that went?’ … I would just sit him down and be like, ‘So what do you think we could change there, pal?’”
Thompson also said the focus on “one specific word” meant the rest of the monologue and the rest of the episode — including a strong showing from new cast member Grace Reiter and musical guest Rosalía — was “overshadowed.”
A Return Trip to Studio 8H After a 2019 Firing
Gillis’ history with SNL goes back to September 2019, when he was announced as a new cast member and then dropped from the show days later. Resurfaced podcast clips showed him using a slur to describe Chinese people and making offensive comments about other groups. SNL called the language “offensive, hurtful and unacceptable” at the time.
He rebuilt his career through stand-up and the Netflix series Tires. In July 2026, he broke two Guinness World Records at a sold-out show at Lincoln Financial Field in Philadelphia: most tickets sold for a comedy show by a solo comedian (77,047) and largest audience for a comedy show (73,946 attendees).
You May Also Like
Gillis’ comments on Rogan’s podcast were his first extended remarks on the SNL monologue since the episode aired. The interview also touched on his view that the reaction was shaped by the broader cultural climate at the time of the broadcast.
Also Read: SNL Halloween Recap: Inde Navarrette Takes Aim at Shane Gillis While Trump Crashes David S. Pumpkins
For more entertainment news and updates, keep reading VvipTimes.




































Leave a Reply