Game of Thrones built its reputation on shocking deaths, but some losses hurt more than others. Years after the series ended, fans still wonder how the story would have changed if certain characters had survived their brutal ends. From the Red Wedding to the final season, here is an alternate look at five character deaths that could have completely reshaped Westeros.
What If Robb Stark Survived the Red Wedding?
The massacre at the Twins remains the most devastating moment in television history. Robb Stark, his mother Catelyn, his pregnant wife Talisa, and most of his northern army were slaughtered at the orders of Walder Frey and Roose Bolton. But what if the Young Wolf had escaped?
A surviving Robb Stark would have maintained the North’s military strength and kept the dream of northern independence alive . His continued presence as King in the North would have created a powerful buffer against both the Lannisters in the south and the White Walker threat beyond the Wall. The Boltons would never have seized control of Winterfell, meaning Sansa Stark and Theon Greyjoy would not have endured their horrific torture at Ramsay Bolton’s hands.
Robb’s survival would have also changed Jon Snow’s path completely. Jon would have remained at the Night’s Watch without being pulled into northern politics. There would have been no need for the Battle of the Bastards, and the northern lords would have stayed united under Robb’s leadership when Daenerys Targaryen finally arrived in Westeros .
If Ned Stark Had Lived: The Honor That Could Have Saved the Realm
Ned Stark’s execution in season one shocked viewers who believed the honorable lord would survive. His death destroyed any chance of peace between the Starks and Lannisters and plunged the Seven Kingdoms into the destructive War of the Five Kings .
With Ned alive, the war might never have happened. As Hand of the King, he would have guided the young king or possibly supported Stannis Baratheon’s claim after discovering Joffrey’s true parentage. The Stark children’s journeys would have been completely different. Arya might never have crossed the Narrow Sea to train with the Faceless Men. Sansa would have learned politics from her father rather than becoming a pawn in King’s Landing. Bran might never have ventured beyond the Wall to become the Three-Eyed Raven .
Ned’s survival would have preserved the Stark family unity that made them so beloved. His wisdom and honor could have influenced key events, potentially preventing Daenerys from turning King’s Landing into ashes.
Oberyn Martell Wins His Fight: The Viper’s Victory Changes Everything
Oberyn Martell came heartbreakingly close to defeating Gregor Clegane in single combat. He had the Mountain defeated but lost focus while demanding a confession, leading to his brutal death. If Oberyn had simply finished the fight, everything changes.
A victorious Oberyn would have secured justice for his sister Elia Martell and her children, potentially preventing the chaos that later consumed Dorne . His survival would have given House Martell a powerful voice at court and a burning desire to see the Lannisters fall. Tyrion Lannister would have been cleared of Joffrey’s murder, meaning he never flees to Essos and never becomes Daenerys’s advisor.
Oberyn’s combat skills and political cunning would have made him a dangerous enemy to the remaining Lannisters. When Daenerys eventually invaded, Oberyn would have been a powerful early ally, potentially changing the entire dynamic of her campaign and preventing her isolation that led to tragedy.
Tywin Lannister Lives: The Lion Who Held His House Together
Tywin Lannister’s death at his son Tyrion’s hands on the privy eliminated the man who held House Lannister together through pure fear and competence. Without Tywin, the house crumbled under Cersei’s increasingly reckless rule.
A surviving Tywin would never have allowed Cersei to create the Faith Militant or blow up the Great Sept of Baelor. He would have managed Tommen properly and maintained Lannister control over the Seven Kingdoms. The alliance with the Tyrells would have remained strong, and the realm would have enjoyed relative stability .
Tywin’s survival also means Varys never flees to join Daenerys, potentially delaying or altering her invasion plans. The Spider’s intelligence network would have remained in King’s Landing, and Daenerys would have faced a united, well-led Westeros rather than the chaos she found. The Long Night might have played out very differently with Tywin commanding the southern forces alongside the northern army.
Daenerys Targaryen Never Turns: The Dragon Queen’s True Ending
The most controversial death in the series remains Daenerys Targaryen’s descent into madness and her killing by Jon Snow. Many fans felt her transformation happened too quickly, destroying years of character development .
What if Daenerys had resisted the urge to burn King’s Landing? If she had conquered the city without mass destruction, her arrival in Westeros would have looked very different. The people might have accepted her as a liberator rather than a tyrant. Jon’s revelation about his true parentage would still have created tension, but Daenerys would have entered that conversation with the moral high ground intact.
Some fans have theorized that Daenerys’s actions were actually calculated to destroy the Iron Throne itself rather than simply seize power . If she had survived with her dragons and her army intact, she could have truly “broken the wheel” and established a new system of governance. Her death eliminated the last dragon rider and ended the Targaryen line forever, but a living Daenerys might have ushered in a new era for Westeros.
How These Changes Ripple Through the Story
The interconnected nature of Game of Thrones means saving one character creates massive changes throughout the narrative . If Robb Stark lives, Jon Snow never becomes King in the North and might never catch Daenerys’s attention. If Ned Stark survives, Arya never becomes a supernatural assassin and might never kill the Night King. If Tywin lives, Cersei never destroys her enemies and Daenerys faces a completely different military situation.
These changes wouldn’t just affect individual storylines but would fundamentally alter the themes of the series. Game of Thrones explored how power corrupts, how honor can be fatal, and how the game of thrones leaves no true winners. The deaths that made the show famous served these larger purposes, forcing characters to grow and adapt while creating unprecedented tension for viewers .
Also Read:
The Legacy of Loss in Game of Thrones
Years after the finale, discussions about these pivotal deaths continue among fans. The Red Wedding remains a cultural touchstone referenced in countless other shows. Ned Stark’s execution set the tone for an entire decade of television. These deaths proved that no character was safe and that storytelling could be both brutal and meaningful .
While alternate realities offer comforting possibilities, the losses in Game of Thrones created the show’s identity. Robb’s death demonstrated the cost of breaking vows. Ned’s death showed that honor without power accomplishes nothing. Oberyn’s death proved that pride leads to destruction. Tywin’s death revealed that even the most powerful figures can fall in undignified ways. And Daenerys’s death raised uncomfortable questions about power and redemption that viewers still debate today.
The show’s willingness to kill beloved characters revolutionized television and continues to influence how modern series approach character mortality . These deaths weren’t just shock value—they were carefully crafted plot points that propelled the story forward in unexpected ways, creating the cultural phenomenon that Game of Thrones remains to this day.
Also Read: Rival Kings Question Pendragon Bloodline: The Pendragon Cycle Episode 5 Sees Merlin Face His Past
For more deep dives into your favorite shows and movies, keep reading VvipTimes for the best coverage of television’s most unforgettable moments.
