Elsbeth Season 3 Episode 7: A Pop Star, a Convent, and a Murder

The newest episode of Elsbeth brings a bizarre crime to the heart of New York City. Titled “And Then There Were Nuns,” the episode places the quirky attorney in a sacred setting disrupted by a pop star’s ambitious project and a deadly secret. This installment continues the show’s tradition of mixing strange crimes with sharp detective work.

Fans can mark their calendars for Thursday, November 20, 2025. The episode will air on CBS at 9:00 PM, a slightly earlier time than the show’s usual slot. For those who stream, the episode will be available on Paramount+. Subscribers with a Premium plan can watch it live as it broadcasts, while Essential members can stream it on-demand the following day.

The episode also continues a major story arc for the season. Elsbeth’s son, Teddy, is still investigating the past of mayoral candidate Alec Bloom for a feature article. This ongoing plot adds a layer of ongoing drama to the self-contained weekly cases.

The Episode’s Mysterious Plot

The official plot for “And Then There Were Nuns” sets up a classic Elsbeth scenario where glamour clashes with tradition, leading to murder. The story begins when a pop star makes a surprising real estate purchase.

Lindsey Normington plays the pop star, Alaia Jade, who buys a struggling convent. What seems like a simple business investment quickly turns into a nightmare when a murder occurs on the sacred grounds. Elsbeth must step in to solve the case, finding herself facing off against the convent’s formidable leader.

The episode’s official synopsis reads: “A pop star’s purchase of a failing convent turns divine real estate into a murder scene as Elsbeth takes on the Mother of all nuns. Meanwhile, Teddy digs into Alec Bloom’s past for a feature he is working on.”

This marks the second episode this season to feature Sarah Steele as Marissa Gold, the campaign manager for Alec Bloom. Marissa has previously schemed to set up a public relationship between Elsbeth and the mayoral candidate to boost his polls, making Teddy’s investigation into Bloom’s past particularly tense.

A Stellar Guest Cast

A significant highlight of this episode is the appearance of acclaimed actress Dianne Wiest in a guest-starring role. She plays Reverend Mother Constance Mary Cabot, the Mother Superior of the convent. Her character is expected to add a powerful presence to the story.

Showrunner Jonathan Tolins shared his personal connection to working with Wiest again, having first worked with her 41 years ago as a theater apprentice.

“I hate to pick favorites,” Tolins said, but noted that having Wiest on the show was “a special thrill.” He added, “Everyone’s just having such a great time. It’s a thrill, a special thrill for me… to be working with her now in this capacity is just a special thrill.”

The main cast members all return for this episode. Carrie Preston leads as the brilliant and unconventional Elsbeth Tascioni, with Wendell Pierce back as Captain C.W. Wagner.

Where to Watch and Catch Up

For viewers looking to watch the episode, the primary channel is CBS on television. For cord-cutters, Paramount+ is the official streaming home for new episodes. The platform offers various subscription tiers, so fans should check their plan to know if they can watch live or the next day.

The show has also moved from the Drama to the Comedy categories for the upcoming awards season, a shift that reflects its unique tone which blends procedural mystery with humor.

After this episode, the show will take a brief break for the Thanksgiving holiday before returning with new episodes.

A Unique Show Format

Elsbeth stands out from other crime shows by often using a “howcatchem” format instead of a “whodunit.” In most episodes, the audience sees the killer commit the crime at the beginning. The suspense comes from watching Elsbeth’s unique and perceptive methods as she pieces together the clues to corner the criminal.

This structure allows Carrie Preston’s charming and quirky performance to take center stage, making each case a fun puzzle for the audience to solve alongside the main character. The series is a spin-off from the popular shows The Good Wife and The Good Fight, where Preston’s character of Elsbeth Tascioni first became a fan favorite.

Credits: IMDb

---