The new family drama It’s Not Like That is continuing its weekly release on Prime Video, with viewers following the gentle story of a widowed pastor and his divorced friend. The show, featuring Scott Foley and Erinn Hayes, has reached its midpoint, and Episode 5 titled “Cold Salami” is the next installment for fans. This series, which blends family dynamics with themes of faith and new beginnings, premiered on January 25, 2026. For those catching up or marking their calendars, here are all the details for the upcoming episode and what the story has covered so far.
When and Where to Watch Episode 5
Episode 5 of It’s Not Like That will be available to stream on Sunday, February 15, 2026. Following the show’s consistent weekly pattern, the episode is expected to drop on the streaming platform at 12:00 AM Pacific Time / 3:00 AM Eastern Time.
The series is available exclusively through the Wonder Project channel, which is an add-on service within Amazon Prime Video. This means you need both a Prime Video subscription and the Wonder Project channel to watch. The first episode was made available for free to U.S. Prime subscribers, but ongoing access requires the channel add-on.
As of now, the confirmed global release is for the United States. Information about a wider international release on Prime Video platforms in other countries is expected to be announced at a later date.
A Quick Recap of the Season So Far
For those who need a refresher before the new episode, the series centers on Malcolm Jeffries (Scott Foley), a pastor grieving his wife Jenny, and Lori Soto (Erinn Hayes), his late wife’s best friend who is navigating a recent divorce. Living across the street from each other in suburban Georgia, they lean on their friendship for support while raising their five combined children.
The premiere episode established their close bond and the complicated feelings beginning to surface between them, culminating in an impulsive kiss. Episode 2, “New Voices,” dealt with the immediate aftermath of that kiss, as Malcolm wrestled with his role in the church and Lori went on her first post-divorce date. The third episode, “Transition Townhomes,” saw Malcolm encouraging his family to donate his late wife’s belongings, while Lori’s ex-husband David’s jealousy began to create tension. The most recent episode, “The Space I Keep For You,” which aired on February 8, focused on Lori and David working together professionally, which strained their co-parenting relationship further.
The children have their own layered storylines, dealing with grief, shifting friendships, and school pressures. Flora, Malcolm’s oldest daughter, has been questioning her faith since her mother’s death. Casey, Lori’s daughter, left the cheerleading squad to join the wrestling team, causing a rift with her former best friend Penelope.
What Critics and Viewers Are Saying
Since its debut, It’s Not Like That has been described as a cozy, multigenerational family drama. Reviewers have highlighted the show’s relatable approach to faith and its focus on real human emotions. One review noted the series “doesn’t hit you over the head” with its faith-based elements, instead presenting them in a way that feels natural to the characters’ lives.
The core strength of the show, according to critics, is the chemistry between its two lead actors. “The chemistry between Hayes and Foley is so good that you’ll want to see Malcolm and Lori navigate this tumultuous time,” wrote Joel Keller for Decider, who gave the series a “Stream It” recommendation. The performances of the young actors playing the children have also been praised for feeling authentic and not overly mature for their age.
The show has drawn comparisons to classic family-centric series like 7th Heaven and Once and Again, offering a modern take on the genre.
Also Read:
What to Expect in the Rest of Season 1
With Episode 5, the series moves into the second half of its eight-episode first season. The official title for Episode 5 is “Cold Salami,” though specific plot details are being kept under wraps. Based on the ongoing storylines, viewers can expect to see the continued development of Malcolm and Lori’s relationship as they face the practical and emotional challenges of their growing connection.
The tension between Lori and her ex-husband David, played by J.R. Ramirez, is likely to continue, especially regarding his apparent jealousy of Malcolm. The children’s stories will also progress, including whether Casey will find acceptance on the wrestling team and if Penelope will stand up to her new friends.
The remaining release schedule for It’s Not Like That Season 1 is as follows:
- Episode 5: February 15, 2026
- Episode 6: February 22, 2026
- Episode 7: March 1, 2026
- Episode 8 (Season Finale): March 8, 2026
The series has not yet been renewed for a second season.
Also Read: It’s Not Like That Season 1 Release Info, Episode Guide, Cast and Streaming Details
Find more guides to your favorite shows and their upcoming episodes right here on VvipTimes.
