A key villain in Percy Jackson and the Olympians Season 2 has received a major upgrade from the books, creating what many fans are calling a masterstroke in adaptation. The Disney+ series has reimagined the sorceress Circe, transforming her from a brief, cartoonish obstacle into a layered and deeply unsettling character with clear, relatable motivations. This change represents the show’s confident approach to adapting Rick Riordan’s beloved novels for television while deepening the story’s emotional themes.
Played by Rosemarie DeWitt, Circe appears in Season 2, Episode 5, titled “We Check In to C.C.’s Spa and Resort”. While the episode follows the book’s basic plot—Percy and Annabeth become stranded on her island, where Percy is turned into a guinea pig—the context and depth of her character are entirely new. The show’s creators have shifted her from a simple misandrist who turns men into animals into a cunning figure whose villainy is rooted in palpable human emotion.
How the Show Changed Circe from the Book
In The Sea of Monsters, the second novel which Season 2 adapts, Circe is a more straightforward and fleeting antagonist. She runs a spa island where she offers magical makeovers to demigod women like Annabeth, while turning all men who arrive into guinea pigs, ranting about her hatred for men and the lack of recognition female heroes receive. Her role is confined to roughly one chapter, serving as a quirky but not deeply threatening stop on the heroes’ journey.
The television series makes several significant alterations:
- Modernized and Sinister Operation: Circe’s island is presented as a full resort, a front for an elaborate long-term scheme. She doesn’t just transform people immediately; she manipulates demigods, feeding on their fears and insecurities to convince them to stay voluntarily, sometimes for decades.
- Revised Motivation: The show removes the overt “hatred of men” theme. Instead, her actions are driven by a fear of abandonment. After centuries of being left behind by those she helps, she has created a system to ensure she is never alone again, trapping demigods under the guise of helping them overcome their flaws.
- Method of Transformation: In the book, Percy is tricked into drinking a magic smoothie. In the show, Circe blows a magical powder from a shell-shaped compact into his face to transform him.
This overhaul changes the scene from a bizarre encounter to a tense psychological thriller, where the danger isn’t just physical transformation but the manipulation of one’s deepest fears.
Why This Villain Change Is a “Masterstroke”
Adapting book villains for the screen is challenging; what works on the page can seem one-dimensional when filmed. The change to Circe is being praised because it avoids this pitfall, delivering a villain who feels real and relevant to the show’s broader themes.
The update gives Circe clear, tragic motives. Her fear of abandonment makes her sympathetic, even as her methods of trapping people are monstrous. This complexity forces both Percy and the audience to engage more deeply with the story’s central question: what truly makes a monster?. This theme runs throughout Season 2, seen also in the portrayal of Percy’s brother Tyson, a Cyclops who defies his kind’s monstrous reputation.
“By framing Circe’s story through her own fear, Percy Jackson and the Olympians shows there is more to her than just cruelty,” one analysis notes, comparing the approach to the humanization of Medusa in Season 1.
The change also demonstrates the creative team’s confidence. Rather than recreating the book scene-for-scene, they interpreted it for a visual medium, adding new layers that strengthen the original themes. It provides a fresh experience for book readers while offering a more compelling narrative for new viewers.
Fan and Critical Reaction to the New Circe
The reaction to this nuanced take on Circe has been largely positive. Fans and critics have noted that Rosemarie DeWitt’s performance brings a quiet, calculating menace that is more frightening than an over-the-top portrayal. The character’s dignified and purposeful demeanor makes her island feel like a serious psychological challenge rather than a silly pitstop.
Discussions online highlight that this change continues the show’s trend of adding depth to mythological figures who were sometimes simple antagonists in the books. This approach enriches the world, showing that conflicts are rarely black and white, especially when the gods themselves are often petty and neglectful.
Also Read:
Other Key Changes in Percy Jackson Season 2
The reworking of Circe is one of several deliberate changes the show has made in its second season. Another significant update is the recasting of Chris Rodriguez, a demigod son of Hermes. The role was played by Andrew Alvarez in Season 1 but is now played by Kevin Chacon in Season 2.
Show creators explained this was not a simple recast but a “course-correct” because they plan to expand Chris’s storyline significantly beyond his minor role in the books. In the later novels, Chris falls in with Luke’s army and suffers a tragic fate before being cured and forming a relationship with Clarisse La Rue. The show appears to be laying the groundwork for this emotional arc earlier and more prominently.
Author Rick Riordan addressed the balance between adaptation and faithfulness, telling sources, “anytime you translate from one media to another, you have to make changes.” He assured that the entire team feels “a sense of obligation and respect toward the material”.
Actor Daniel Diemer, who plays Tyson, echoed this sentiment, stating, “Even if things are changing, the heart of the books and the heart of the characters, that remains the same”.
Other changes in Season 2 include the introduction of an original character, Alison Simms, a daughter of Apollo in Luke’s rebellion who does not appear in the books, and adjusted sequences like using Laistrygonian giants instead of Colchis Bulls in the premiere episode.
Percy Jackson and the Olympians Season 2 is currently streaming on Disney+, with new episodes releasing weekly. The season adapts the plot of The Sea of Monsters, following Percy, Annabeth, and his new brother Tyson on a quest to the Bermuda Triangle to rescue Grover and retrieve the Golden Fleece to save Camp Half-Blood.
Also Read: The Judge Returns Release Schedule: Full Episode Calendar and Streaming Guide
