The Beauty said goodbye to one of its lead actors. Rebecca Hall, who began the series as FBI Agent Jordan Bennett, has exited the show following a dramatic and grotesque transformation at the end of the three-part premiere. The actress has now shared her thoughts on the shocking twist that saw her character infected by the show’s namesake virus, leading to a complete physical change and her replacement by another actor.
The new Ryan Murphy series, which debuted on January 21, 2026, on FX and Hulu, explores a world where a sexually transmitted disease can rewrite a person’s DNA to make them conventionally beautiful, but with violent and often fatal side effects. Hall’s character, Agent Jordan Bennett, and her partner Cooper Madsen (Evan Peters) were tasked with investigating the outbreak before Jordan herself fell victim to it.
What Happened to Jordan Bennett in Episode 3
The climax of The Beauty’s third episode confirmed the terrifying consequence of Jordan Bennett’s infection. After a one-night stand in Venice, Jordan contracted the virus. By the end of the episode, the transformation process was complete. The character emerged from a slimy cocoon, but not as Rebecca Hall. She was now portrayed by a different actress, Jessica Alexander, marking a sudden and permanent recast for the role.
This leaves her FBI partner, Cooper Madsen, in a desperate race against time. Jordan is now missing, and her new face makes her impossible to find through conventional means. Furthermore, she carries a corrupted, stolen variant of the virus that causes victims to eventually bleed from their eyes and explode. Cooper’s primary mission has shifted from stopping a global outbreak to saving his partner from this gruesome fate before it is too late.
Rebecca Hall’s Reaction to the Sudden Exit
Despite her leading role being cut short, Rebecca Hall expressed enthusiasm for the bold storytelling choice. She praised the twist as being perfectly aligned with the show’s dark themes about vanity and identity.
“I thought it was interesting and exciting and fun, like, why not?” Hall said about the decision to kill off her character’s original appearance.
She specifically appreciated the homage to classic thriller structures, comparing her role to that of Janet Leigh in Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho—a major star whose early departure shocks the audience and upends expectations.
Hall was actively involved in filming Jordan’s bodily breakdown before the cocoon stage. She performed much of the intense physical acting herself, which involved violent writhing and contortions.
“That scene was done in little pieces… It was choreographed and the body double did some of the more circus-level stuff. But it is me a lot of the time, which was surprising when I watched it honestly,” Hall explained. “I like that stuff — I’m very game for a bit of physical business”.
How the Twist Connects to the Show’s Core Message
The brutal transformation of a main character is not just for shock value. It serves as the ultimate example of the show’s critique of beauty standards and the dangerous pursuit of perfection. Hall has spoken about how the series made her reflect on these themes in modern society.
“I appreciate that it’s something that has helped me do my job, being looked at is part of it, but I also, of course, realize that that is a rather ephemeral commodity and is dangerous to invest too much of your worth in,” Hall said.
She pointed out the paradox of an era where people can increasingly “pay to be ‘perfect,’” questioning whose standard of beauty they are chasing. Her character’s story arc—an accomplished FBI agent whose identity is completely erased and rewritten by a superficial ideal—becomes a central horror story for the series.
Evan Peters, who plays Cooper Madsen and serves as an executive producer, highlighted that creator Ryan Murphy often builds his shows around celebrating uniqueness.
“Ryan always has a through line in his shows of the thing that makes you unique and different is the thing that makes you interesting and should be celebrated,” Peters stated.
Jordan’s loss directly challenges this idea, presenting a world where the very thing that makes you “you” can be violently stripped away.
The Story Consequences of Jordan’s Transformation
Jordan Bennett’s new identity creates immediate complications for the plot. The FBI has lost a key agent, and Cooper has lost his partner and friend. His personal drive to find a cure is now powerfully motivated by his desire to save Jordan.
Meanwhile, the episode also followed the assassin Antonio (Anthony Ramos), who works for the virus’s creator, billionaire Byron Frost (Ashton Kutcher). Antonio’s mission is to eliminate anyone infected with the stolen, imperfect variant of the virus to protect its exclusivity for the wealthy elite. This puts a target on the new Jordan’s back, adding another layer of danger.
In a parallel storyline, Antonio recruits Jeremy (Jeremy Pope), another infected individual who has embraced his violent new instincts. This contrasts with Jordan’s fate, suggesting different people react to the virus in different ways. The show sets up a conflict between those who want to control the virus for profit and power, and those who are tragically caught in its wake, like Jordan.
Also Read:
Behind the Scenes of the Body Horror
The physical transformation required extensive and messy practical effects. While Hall did not have to endure the cocoon pod herself, her co-star Jeremy Pope was the first to undergo the process, which he described as a wild experience.
“It was a lot of K-Y Jelly, and a lot of goo,” Pope said, noting that Murphy used his transformation as a template for the others in the series.
Pope approached the scene not as pure horror, but as a painful rebirth, with Alvin Ailey music playing on set to create a sense of “spiritual awakening”. Hall, who watched Pope’s process, was relieved she did not have to participate in that particular step.
The episode also featured other grotesque moments that define the show’s tone, including a character exploding in a cafeteria and another contracting the virus through a drop of blood in his eye. This blend of high-fashion aesthetics with extreme body horror is a signature of the Ryan Murphy production.
Also Read: Netflix Releases New Bridgerton Season 4 Photos Previewing Benedict’s Love Story and More
