A small cassette tape in Stranger Things Season 5 has become the center of a major fan prediction. In the first part of the final season, Jonathan Byers receives a secret engagement ring for Nancy Wheeler, but his hesitation to propose has viewers worried about his fate. With the main characters trapped in danger, fans online are sharing a heartbreaking theory that this hidden ring will only be found after a tragic ending.
The Ring Clue That Started the Theory
The theory began with a specific moment in Stranger Things Season 5, Episode 3. The character Murray Bauman gives Jonathan a cassette tape. Inside, Jonathan finds an engagement ring meant for Nancy. Murray pushes Jonathan to propose, telling him to “get it over with”. However, after a Demogorgon attacks Nancy’s family, Jonathan decides to wait. The ring is not seen again in the first four episodes.
This detail made fans suspicious. Why show the ring so clearly if it is not used right away? Many believe it is a classic storytelling clue, often called “Chekhov’s gun,” where an object shown early becomes important later. Online, viewers started to connect the ring to a potential tragic end for Jonathan.
“Jonathan has a ring in the cassette. Don’t hate me!!! Jonathan dies and Nancy later finds the ring,” posted a fan named C Anna Thomas on a Stranger Things Facebook group.
The Viral “Vecna’ed” Theory
The most popular idea spreading online is that Jonathan could become Vecna’s next victim. Fans recall that Vecna’s victims are often saved by hearing their favorite music. The theory suggests that if Jonathan is attacked, Nancy might try to save him by finding his favorite song on the cassette. When she looks for the tape, she would then discover the ring inside.
This would create a moment mixing love and deep sadness, as Nancy would learn of Jonathan’s plan only after he is gone or lost to the Upside Down. By the end of the released episodes, Jonathan, Nancy, Steve, and Dustin are all shown to be in serious danger within the Upside Down, making this dark possibility feel real to many viewers.
A Love Triangle’s Painful Twist
The theory gets more complicated because of the long-running connection between Nancy, Jonathan, and Steve Harrington. Some fans think that if Jonathan dies, Steve and Nancy might end up together. This leads to another painful idea: Steve could be the one to find the cassette first.
In this situation, Steve would see the ring and know Jonathan’s intention. He would then face a terrible choice: tell Nancy and possibly hurt his own chance with her, or keep it a secret to protect her from more pain. This would put Steve’s character, often seen as a protector, in a very difficult position.
Other fans have imagined an even more dramatic twist where Steve sacrifices himself instead. In this version, Jonathan might tell Steve about the ring before a dangerous mission. If Steve then sacrificed his life to save Jonathan, his final act could be telling Jonathan, “Tell her yourself”. This would turn the ring from a symbol of Jonathan’s love into a symbol of Steve’s heroism.
Could Jonathan’s Story Be About Regret?
Not all theories focus on death. Another idea suggests that Nancy could die before Jonathan ever proposes. In this sad ending, Jonathan would be left holding the ring, full of regret for waiting too long. This would connect directly to Murray’s earlier advice about not delaying important moments. The ring would then represent a lost future and Jonathan’s personal guilt, making his survival the painful part of the story.
Also Read:
What the Show’s Creators Have Said
While fans are deep in speculation, the show’s creators, the Duffer Brothers, have recently commented on other popular theories. In a recent interview, they clearly stated that some big fan ideas are not true. For example, they confirmed that the beloved character Eddie Munson will not return as a vampire, and that the entire story is not just a Dungeons & Dragons game being played in Mike Wheeler’s basement.
However, they have not commented on any theories about Jonathan, Nancy, or the ring. This silence keeps the mystery alive. The Duffer Brothers have also mentioned they studied many famous TV finales, aiming for an ending that feels true to their show rather than trying to be overly clever.
When to Expect Answers
The wait for answers is almost over. Stranger Things Season 5, Volume 2 is scheduled to release on December 25, 2025 in the U.S. The final episode of the series will arrive on December 31, 2025. These final episodes will show if the fan theories about the ring and Jonathan’s fate are correct, or if the story holds a different surprise for viewers around the world.
Also Read: Severance Season 2: Who Brought Apple TV’s Twisted Office to Life?
