After five seasons, the Dutton family’s story has reached its conclusion. The series finale of Yellowstone aired on Sunday, December 15, 2024, drawing a record 11.4 million viewers . While the episode provided closure for some characters, fans are left with a long list of storylines that were introduced with drama, only to be completely forgotten .
From a missing bomb to a secret past, the show’s creator, Taylor Sheridan, has a habit of setting up major plots that never get a resolution . This has become a signature trait of the series, leaving audiences with more questions than answers as the final credits rolled .
The Early Mysteries: Bones, Bombs, and a Missing Horse
Some of the show’s longest-running loose ends date all the way back to its first seasons. These forgotten plots teased major consequences for the Dutton ranch that simply never arrived.
One of the earliest and most talked-about abandoned stories involves Tate Dutton. In Season 1, young Tate discovered dinosaur bones on the ranch land . The moment seemed hugely important, as the discovery of fossils could have legally protected the land from developers. After a drone was seen hovering over the site, someone broke into the family’s house and stole the bones . Despite this dramatic setup, the stolen dinosaur bones were never mentioned again in the entire series .
Another major Season 2 plot hole involves a literal ticking time bomb. In a tense scene, Kayce Dutton and an associate planted an explosive device on the private plane owned by their enemies, the Beck Brothers . Fans waited for the plane to blow up, but it never did. The Beck Brothers were killed in other ways, and the bomb on the aircraft was never referenced again, leaving viewers to wonder about its fate .
“Still waiting for the bomb on the airplane to blow up on Yellowstone,” one fan noted online, highlighting the lasting confusion .
Tate was also at the center of another dropped storyline involving a horse. In Season 2, John Dutton gave his grandson a horse named Lucky on the condition that Tate care for it. The horse served as a catalyst for Tate’s kidnapping but then disappeared from the story entirely, never to be seen or mentioned again .
Unconfirmed Fates and Unaired Scenes
The show has also left the ultimate fate of key villains ambiguous, fueling years of fan theories that ultimately led nowhere.
The death of villain Malcolm Beck was never shown on screen . After being shot by John Dutton in the Season 2 finale, the character was left in the wilderness, but viewers never saw him die . This led to widespread belief that he was still alive and would return for revenge. Actor Neal McDonough even hinted in interviews that his character might come back . These theories peaked when the Duttons were attacked at the start of Season 4, with many fans guessing Beck was the mastermind. He wasn’t, and his status remains officially unknown .
Adding to the Malcolm Beck mystery was a promotional trailer for Season 4 that was never part of the actual show. The trailer featured a distinct white hat floating down a river, followed by a trail of blood . The hat was identical to the one Malcolm Beck always wore, strongly hinting at his demise . However, this dramatic scene never appeared in any episode, leaving fans who saw the promo even more confused about the character’s story .
Season 5’s Pile of Unfinished Business
The final season introduced several new characters and conflicts that were built up as major threats, only to be abruptly dropped when the show returned from its mid-season break.
A new Sheriff arrived after the death of the previous one, immediately clashing with the Duttons by arresting Beth . He warned John he wouldn’t be corrupt like his predecessor, setting the stage for a showdown. That showdown never happened, as the character vanished after just one episode .
One of the most ominous threats involved a pack of wolves. Ranch hands accidentally shot the wolves, not realizing they were endangered and fitted with government tracking tags . An investigation pointed directly to the Yellowstone, posing a serious legal threat. Rip Wheeler tried to cover it up. When the show returned for its final episodes, this entire storyline was gone without any explanation .
The corporate antagonist Sarah Atwood was revealed to have a hidden past. Beth Dutton discovered that “Sarah Atwood” was not her real name, but was digging into her true identity . This mystery was left completely unresolved when the character was killed off later in the season . Her ultimate motives and who she was really working for remained unclear .
A political challenge on the Broken Rock Reservation also went nowhere. Attorney Angela Blue Thunder returned to challenge Chief Thomas Rainwater’s leadership, promising to oust him as chairman . After setting up this power struggle, the character and the entire plotline were absent from the second half of the season .
Finally, a subplot meant to develop Carter’s character was abandoned. His girlfriend, Halie, appeared in several episodes in the first half of Season 5 and then vanished without a trace . The only remnant was a brief comment from another cowboy noting that Carter seemed happy .
Deep Family Mysteries Left Unexplained
Beyond seasonal plots, the show introduced fundamental mysteries about the Dutton family’s history and relationships that were never explained, leaving character motivations unclear.
A major question surrounds the bitter relationship between John and Kayce Dutton. In a flashback, John branded his own son Kayce for the “crime” of marrying Monica and having a child with her . The branding is a brutal punishment reserved for the worst offenders on the ranch. The show never fully explained why John reacted so severely to Kayce’s marriage or why he never expressed regret or provided context for this extreme action, even as their relationship improved .
The origins of Jamie Dutton’s adoption are another deep mystery. Jamie’s biological father, Garrett Randall, killed his mother, Phyllis. John told Jamie he took him in as an infant because he knew his mother and wanted to save him . The nature of John’s relationship with Phyllis was never revealed, leading to fan theories that she might have been a relative or close family friend. Her story begins and ends with this single mention .
The toxic dynamic between Beth Dutton and her late mother, Evelyn, also lacks context. A childhood accident involving a horse led to Evelyn’s death, and in her final moments, Evelyn was harsh and cold to a young Beth . The show never explored why the mother-daughter relationship was so strained, even though this trauma is the core of Beth’s character .
Also Read:
Finale Lingering Questions
The series finale wrapped up the fate of the ranch, but it also created new questions and failed to address ongoing character secrets.
A central mystery that lasted the entire series is whether Rip Wheeler knows the full truth about Beth’s past. Beth has never told Rip that she was once pregnant with his child or that Jamie arranged for her to have a hysterectomy, making her infertile . This secret is at the heart of Beth’s rage, yet she never shared it with her husband, leaving a gap in their relationship that was never addressed .
The fate of longtime ranch hand Lloyd Pierce was left uncertain. After the ranch was dissolved, Rip offered Lloyd a job at his new ranch. Lloyd declined, saying if he couldn’t work at the Yellowstone, he wouldn’t be a cowboy at all . The finale did not reveal what the beloved character, whose entire identity was tied to the ranch, planned to do next .
Fans also question how Beth and Rip seamlessly avoided consequences for Jamie’s murder. They killed the state attorney general in his home in broad daylight and disposed of his body . Given that Jamie was already under investigation, the lack of any serious police scrutiny over his disappearance stretches believability .
Finally, a hanging threat from earlier seasons was forgotten. Beth once discovered that Jamie had a secret son with his former assistant, Christina. She vowed to take the child from Jamie if he ever betrayed the family again . After Jamie’s betrayal and death, this threat was never mentioned or acted upon, leaving the child’s fate unknown .
Also Read: Seven Sisters: Elizabeth Olsen’s New Family Drama Moves Forward on Hulu
