Filmmaker Karan Johar has openly criticised a growing pattern in Bollywood where lead actors demand aggressive, “alpha” characters and try to control everything from trailer cuts to VFX budgets. In a candid conversation with Anupama Chopra for The Hollywood Reporter India’s InFocus series, Johar questioned why actors are more focused on becoming box office experts than on their actual craft.
The filmmaker, who has spent over three decades in the Hindi film industry, said he has personally seen narrations come to a halt because an actor felt their character was not “alpha enough” or “front-footed enough.” His blunt question to those actors: “When are you acting exactly?”
Actors Want to Be Everything Except Actors
Johar described the current situation as a “herd mentality” where artists and filmmakers are moving away from their instincts and following what they believe will succeed at the box office.
He listed the many roles actors now want to play beyond acting: box office gurus, trade analysts, perception setters, campaign makers, trailer cutters, and poster makers.
“I’m flummoxed with people’s insecurities. Maybe it’s vulnerabilities, but I’m reading them as insecurities. I’m surprised and shocked that they want to do everything but act. They want to become box-office gurus, trade analysts, perception setters, campaign makers, trailer cutters and poster makers. When are you acting exactly?”
The questions actors ask during project discussions have also left Johar puzzled. He revealed that actors frequently want to know whether a film is “deeply rooted,” what the VFX budget is, and why certain casting choices were made.
“I’ve had actors ask me if the film has anything deeply rooted. What does that mean? Rooted in what? I hope it’s rooted in a great script. I hope it’s rooted in great content. We are making a Hindi-language film or an Indian film which is rooted in the language and the syntax of our cinema. Isn’t that enough?”
On the VFX budget question, his response was direct: “How is that your problem? Will I make a tacky-looking film because I want to make money off a bad film? No, I’ll obviously do my best.”
The ‘Alpha’ Obsession and the DDLJ Example
Johar pointed out that actors are increasingly rejecting characters that do not fit a certain aggressive, dominant mould. He recalled lead actors stopping narrations with comments like, “This character is not alpha enough” or “This character is not front-footed enough.”
To challenge this thinking, Johar brought up Shah Rukh Khan’s Raj from Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge (1995) . Raj was not an aggressive hero. Instead of fighting Simran’s father, he chose to seek his blessings before marrying her.
“Was Shah Rukh Khan front-footed in Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge? He was the most beautifully passive character. He said, ‘I will not fight your father. I will take your father’s blessings and your parents’ blessings and only then will I marry you.’ Isn’t that the biggest love story of our times?”
Johar also cited Saiyaara (2025) , which featured Ahaan Panday as an empathetic romantic lead, as proof that softer male characters can succeed commercially. He contrasted this with the popularity of more aggressive protagonists in films like Kabir Singh (2019) , Animal (2023) , and Dhurandhar.
His argument was simple: audiences have embraced different kinds of heroes, so why are actors only chasing one template?
Filmmakers Are ‘Complicit’ in This Problem
Johar did not place the blame solely on actors. He admitted that directors and producers have also contributed to this culture by giving in to unreasonable demands simply to avoid conflict on set.
He described filmmakers as “deeply complicit in the creation of this monstrosity.”
However, he made a clear distinction between interference from younger actors and the input of veterans. Johar said he values the opinions of Shah Rukh Khan and Amitabh Bachchan because their experience and understanding of the craft go far beyond his own.
“If Shah Rukh Khan has an opinion, then I will bow down in respect. Not because he is the biggest in the country, but because his experience supersedes mine. If Mr. (Amitabh) Bachchan tells me anything, it’ll be his way,” he said.
Related Stories
A Familiar Concern From the Filmmaker
This is not the first time Johar has spoken against Bollywood’s hyper-masculine trend. In April 2026, he criticised the industry’s “high-octane testosterone” phase, saying that herd mentality leads to repetitive storytelling where every male lead looks and behaves the same.
His latest comments carry the same message: creative conviction is being replaced by calculation, and actors are losing sight of what their job actually is.
Johar’s production house, Dharma Productions, is currently gearing up for the release of its series Student of the Year: After Dark. The show stars Shanaya Kapoor in a double role alongside Divik Sharma, Manya Grover, and Mannat Duggal. Directed by Reema Maya, the series is set to premiere on JioHotstar on November 13, 2026.
For more entertainment news and analysis, keep reading VvipTimes.




































Leave a Reply