Rob Feeley has finally shared his side of the dinner that changed everything on Love Is Blind Season 11. The 40-year-old from Boston admitted he should have protected Michaella Giorgio when his friends made sexual comments to her. He also revealed a serious health battle involving the friend at the center of the backlash. Michaella, meanwhile, has offered a response that few viewers expected.
Rob’s Honest Admission About the Dinner
The dinner with Rob’s five closest friends became one of the most talked-about moments of the season. It aired in Episode 9, released on Wednesday, October 28, 2026. Rob’s friend Jay made a series of inappropriate comments to Michaella shortly after she sat down.
Rob did not stop the comments at the time. Instead, he became upset when the restaurant refused to serve Jay more alcohol. He asked producers to remove microphones and argued with people around him.
In an interview with TODAY, Rob said watching the scene back was difficult.
“I should have stepped in. Hindsight’s 20/20. But looking at it on camera, which I didn’t have the opportunity, there were a lot of situations that I wish I could have taken back, and especially my friend.”
Rob also said he and the friend had a “serious conversation” after watching the episode together. He described the situation as “not a good situation” and “really tough to watch.”
The Friend Who Caused the Backlash
The friend, identified as John “Jay” Oliver, is from East Providence, Rhode Island. He owns a sports bar called The Local and co-owns Moving Dough Pizza. After the episode aired, he deactivated his Instagram account, @joliver_44.
During the dinner, Jay told Michaella she looked like “a hot Italian mother that makes good meatballs, good pasta, and you know how to play around in the bedroom.” He asked if she had an OnlyFans account. He also commented “You washed your hand like I’m from Harlem” after she wiped her hand on her shirt.
Rob told Variety that Jay was battling stage three lung cancer at the time of filming. Jay is now in remission.
“And no excuses for Jay at all. But it might come out later, so I’ll say it. He’s also been battling stage three lung cancer. It was during that time, too. He’s in remission now, but I don’t know where his head was in that moment, and it’s not excusable at all.”
Rob said Jay was “10 times worse” than him about the situation and that Jay’s family was deeply affected. Rob also said he did not know Jay had been drinking before the dinner.
“I didn’t know my one friend [Jay] was going to behave that way. I didn’t know he’d been drinking beforehand.”
Michaella’s Surprising Words About Rob’s Friends
Michaella raised the dinner during the Season 11 reunion, which aired on November 8, 2026. She told Rob she felt the dinner was “disrespectful” and that she would have appreciated “a little bit of protection from him.”
“And it kind of started as soon as I sat down at the table. Just having very s**ual conversations. But I would have appreciated a little bit of protection from him.”
She also said being accused of being on the show for the wrong reasons was “awful.”
“Being accused by one of your friends of being there for the wrong reasons when I truly love you so much and did everything I could to demonstrate that to you was awful.”
But in a separate interview with Vulture, Michaella shared a detail that surprised many viewers. After the awkward dinner, the group actually went out together and had a good time. She described Rob’s friends as “so complimentary and lovely.” The one friend who was “overserved” did not join them.
That same night, however, Michaella said Rob turned on her. She claimed he told her that “no one stands to gain more from this show” than her because she works in women’s fashion. She also said he called her parents “crazy” for supporting the experiment.
No Apology From the Friend Group
Michaella confirmed she did not receive an apology from Rob’s friends for their behavior at the dinner. She spoke about it on the What’s the Reality? podcast.
“No. Yeah. I don’t think it’s going to change anything. And I’m still so proud of myself for how I showed up, you know, and I proved to myself what I can handle. And I think it was a really big learning lesson for Rob as well.”
Rob, for his part, said his friend is “very, very apologetic” to Michaella. He said the friend wishes he could “take it back” every second of the day.
You May Also Like
Rob’s Message to Viewers After the Backlash
The backlash against Rob continued after the reunion. On the Club Ambition podcast, he dismissed the criticism by calling viewers “sheep.”
“Whatever, you guys, you know, I had a couple bad moments, regretfully, learn, grow. But the opinions, the lies don’t affectโฆ the opinions of the sheep.”
He also insisted that he protects women.
“So, for me, it’s you never could understand the tough skin you have to develop when you’re hearing all these lies, all these crazy things. I’m aggressive. I vehemently protect women.”
Rob later shared a lengthy statement on Instagram, apologizing for how he handled certain moments.
“Most importantly, I want to acknowledge the hurt I caused Michaella. Regardless of how I was feeling, she deserved to feel heard, respected, and understood. I’m genuinely sorry for the times I fell short and for how I reacted in certain situations.”
Love Is Blind Season 11 premiered in October 2026 on Netflix. The season followed singles from Boston. Episodes 9 through 11 were released on October 28, 2026. The reunion aired on November 8, 2026. All episodes are streaming on Netflix.
Also Read: Love Is Blindโs Beekeeper Matt Speaks Out on Michaella Split: โJust Two Different Truthsโ
For more similar articles, visit VvipTimes.







































Leave a Reply