Clayface has done something no other DC Universe film has managed. The R-rated body-horror movie opened in theatres on October 23, 2026, and its audience score on Rotten Tomatoes shot to 94%, pushing past James Gunn’s Superman and its 90% Popcornmeter score. The result gives DC Studios its highest-rated theatrical release among filmgoers, and it arrived from a project that was never expected to lead the franchise. A $40 million budget, a first-time leading man, and a villain most casual viewers only knew from cartoons somehow produced the studio’s strongest audience reaction yet.
The Record in Plain Numbers
Clayface debuted with a 94% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes, based on more than 250 verified ratings in its first day. The score briefly touched 95% before settling at 94%, and it continues to shift as more ticket buyers log their reviews.
The comparison with the rest of the DCU makes the gap clear:
- Clayface — 94% audience score, 76% critic score
- Superman (2025) — 90% audience score, 83% critic score
- Blue Beetle — 90% audience score, 78% critic score
- Peacemaker — 83% audience score, 93% critic score
- Creature Commandos — 79% audience score, 93% critic score
- Supergirl (2026) — 72% audience score, 52% critic score
- Lanterns — 67% audience score, 91% critic score
Superman remains the higher-rated film with critics at 83%, and several DCU television projects hold stronger critic scores. The audience record is where Clayface stands alone. The film also tied Batman Begins and The Dark Knight, both of which hold 94% audience scores, for the highest audience rating of any DC movie on the platform.
“Clayface is, without a doubt, a BODY HORROR, and a damn good one! A macabre, visceral, and very well-constructed movie. Tom Rhys is SENSATIONAL as Matt Hagen.” — an early viewer, as cited by Times of India
What Critics Said About the Film
Critics were far less united than audiences. The Tomatometer settled at 76% Certified Fresh from 116 reviews, a solid but not spectacular number that placed the film second among DCU movies behind Superman‘s 83%.
The Hollywood Reporter called it “one of the year’s big surprises,” praising its “psychological depth and emotional resonance” and comparing it to the body-horror work of David Cronenberg and Sam Raimi. USA Today took the opposite view, labelling it “a messy DC miss” and arguing that the screenplay “does almost nothing” with its lead character despite a strong performance from Tom Rhys Harries. Time Out described it as “one of the ickiest body horrors since The Substance“.
The split explains the unusual gap between the two scores. Audiences walked in expecting a gruesome monster movie and largely got one. Critics wanted more from a script that began with Mike Flanagan and was later reshaped by Hossein Amini and director James Watkins.
Why Audiences Turned Out for a Batman Villain
Clayface is the first DCU film built around a villain rather than a hero, and it is the first R-rated entry in the franchise. The character, Matt Hagen, is a rising Hollywood actor whose face is destroyed by a crime boss. An experimental procedure saves his life but turns his body into a shifting, clay-like mass. The film leans into practical effects and body horror rather than cape-and-punch spectacle.
That approach gave the movie a clear identity. The marketing sold a horror film, and the people who bought tickets received one. Tom Rhys Harries carried the lead role after what director James Watkins described as an intense audition process, and critics on both sides of the divide agreed his performance held the film together.
“I wrote a script that I loved and handed it in, and that was basically the end of it. I haven’t even seen the movie yet.” — Mike Flanagan, speaking about his original Clayface screenplay
Box Office and Budget
The audience score arrived alongside a steady but not explosive opening. Clayface earned $3.5 million from Thursday preview screenings on October 22, and projections placed its domestic opening weekend between $20 million and $35 million, with most estimates clustering around $25 million to $30 million.
The film cost a reported $40 million to $44 million to produce. That figure matters more than the raw opening number. A $30 million domestic weekend plus $20 million to $25 million from international markets would put the global opening near $50 million to $55 million, enough to cover the production budget before marketing costs.
For comparison, Superman opened to $125 million domestically and finished with $618.7 million worldwide on a $225 million budget. Supergirl opened to $37.1 million and ended at $126.4 million against a budget of at least $170 million. Clayface does not need to match either film to be a success. It needs to turn a profit on a much smaller bet, and early tracking suggests it is on course to do that.
The Cast and the Team Behind It
Tom Rhys Harries leads as Matt Hagen, the actor who becomes Clayface. Naomi Ackie plays Dr Caitlin Bates, the scientist tied to his transformation. David Dencik, Max Minghella, Eddie Marsan, Nancy Carroll, and Joshua James round out the supporting cast.
James Watkins, known for Eden Lake, The Woman in Black, and Speak No Evil, directed the film. Mike Flanagan wrote the original screenplay, with Hossein Amini handling later revisions. James Gunn and Peter Safran produced through DC Studios.
The film runs 1 hour and 48 minutes, making it one of the shortest entries in the DCU and DCEU.
You May Also Like:
Release Information for Global Viewers
Clayface opened in theatres on Friday, October 23, 2026, through Warner Bros. Pictures. The release covers the USA, UK, Canada, Australia, and India on the same date, with international rollouts following the standard Warner Bros. pattern.
In India, the film released with an A certificate after CBFC-mandated cuts and modifications. The approved runtime is 108.31 minutes. Viewers in India can check local multiplex listings for English and dubbed versions.
The film is rated R in the USA for strong bloody violence, body horror, and language. No streaming date has been announced. The movie does not include a post-credits scene, so audiences can leave once the credits begin.
Also Read: Hugh Jackman’s The Wolverine Finally Gets a New Streaming Home on HBO Max This November
For more box office records and DC Universe coverage, stay with VvipTimes.
Leave a Reply