Marvel fans are in a heated debate after reports claimed Sam Wilson, played by Anthony Mackie, will lead the Avengers in the upcoming Avengers: Doomsday. The news sparked strong reactions online, with some fans excited and others questioning if he’s the right choice.
The rumor started after MCU Film News shared a casting breakdown listing Captain America as the central character, with Black Panther and Shang-Chi in supporting roles. Doctor Strange’s involvement remains unclear. Marvel Studios has not officially confirmed the details, but fans are already arguing over whether Sam Wilson deserves the spotlight.
One fan summed up the support for Wilson by saying:
“People getting mad that CAPTAIN AMERICA has a lead role in the AVENGERS movie???? who the fk else is going to LEAD the avengers???”
Others disagreed, suggesting different heroes like Thor, Doctor Strange, or even Captain Carter should take charge. Some fans feel Wilson lacks the charisma to carry a major team-up film.
“Ughhhh no one wants Sam as the lead. I’d rather see Captain Carter lead 😂,” one fan tweeted.
“Should be Thor or Dr Strange as lead role sigh,” another added.
Race and nostalgia also play a part in the debate. Some fans believe backlash against Wilson stems from bias, while others argue it’s just about personal preference.
“No they mad a black man is the lead and they can’t keep Sam’s name out of their mouth because Steve Rogers is living rent free in their heads,” a netizen said.
Meanwhile, rumors about Chris Evans returning as Steve Rogers—or even an evil version like Captain Hydra—continue to swirl. Comic writer Chris Claremont hinted at Evans playing multiple versions of Cap, including a villainous variant. However, Evans himself denied these claims, saying he’s “happily retired” from the role.
“Yeah, I talk to them all the time. It’s sad to be away. It’s sad to not be back with the band, but I’m sure they’re doing something incredible,” Evans told ScreenRant.
Despite his denial, theories persist. One suggests an alternate universe where Steve Rogers became HYDRA’s Winter Soldier instead of Bucky Barnes. Another rumor claims Evans could return as Nomad, a version of Steve who abandoned the Captain America identity.
The film’s cast includes Anthony Mackie (Captain America), Chris Hemsworth (Thor), Letitia Wright (Black Panther), Simu Liu (Shang-Chi), and Robert Downey Jr. (Doctor Doom). The Russo brothers are directing, and filming is underway to prevent leaks.
Also Read: Marvel Delays Avengers: Doomsday and Secret Wars Release Dates; Check New Timeline
Marvel has not released an official trailer, leaving fans to rely on rumors and speculation. Until an announcement is made, the debate over who should lead the Avengers will likely continue.
Credits: FandomWire
