It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia returned for its seventeenth season in 2025, continuing the story of the dysfunctional Gang from Paddy’s Pub. The season consisted of eight episodes, featuring parodies of popular shows like Abbott Elementary and The Golden Bachelor, alongside the series’ signature dark humor and social satire. Reviews from critics and fans were mixed, with some praising its consistency and others criticizing certain episodes. Based on aggregated ratings and critical opinions, here is the ranking of all episodes from best to worst.
The Gang Gets Ready for Prime Time (Episode 7)
This episode is widely regarded as the standout of the season. It focuses on the Gang preparing for Frank’s appearance on The Golden Bachelor, leading to a meta-commentary on the show itself. Dennis undergoes a breakdown during practice, referencing his humiliation from a season 10 episode. The focus groups providing harsh feedback about the characters add to the hilarity. Critics praised its blend of genuine storytelling and self-awareness, making it the highest-rated episode of the season .
“The episode displays It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia’s ability to blend genuine storytelling and self-awareness.”
Mac and Dennis Become EMTs (Episode 3)
In this episode, Mac and Dennis decide to become emergency medical technicians after witnessing EMTs resuscitate a Paddy’s patron. Meanwhile, Charlie parodies The Bear with his chaotic cooking style. The multiple plot threads converge in a frenetic conclusion, including an ambulance accident and the Gang shifting blame onto their legal counterparts. Reviewers found it hilarious and relentless, with one calling it “charged up twenty minutes of extreme” .
Frank Is in a Coma (Episode 2)
Frank appears to fall into a coma, leading Dee to work through the five stages of grief while the rest of the Gang plots to franchise Paddy’s Pub. The emotional climax reveals Frank’s elaborate betrayal, involving a cake-making show stunt. The episode was praised for its dark humor and emotional depth, with Kaitlin Olson’s performance as Dee receiving particular attention .
The Golden Bachelor Live (Episode 8)
The season finale features Frank as a contestant on a parody of The Golden Bachelor, with Danny DeVito and Carol Kane reuniting since their Taxi days. Frank must choose between a young internet sensation, a confident woman his age, or a familiar face. The episode balances absurdity with touching moments, culminating in a tender tribute to the late Lynne Marie Stewart, who played Charlie’s mom. Critics noted its emotional depth and effective parody .
The Gang F***s Up Abbott Elementary (Episode 1)
This crossover episode with Abbott Elementary shows the Gang’s community service at the school, revealed through security footage and commentary from Abbott characters. While the concept was fun, some viewers felt it worked best for fans of both shows. The Gang’s offensive behavior and lack of self-awareness were highlighted, making it a polarizing but memorable episode .
Overage Drinking: A National Concern (Episode 6)
A follow-up to a season 1 episode, this installment sees the return of Tammy and Trey, now in their 40s, to retrieve their teenage son from Paddy’s Pub. Dennis and Dee attempt to reconnect with their former prom dates, while Mac and Charlie search for a missing Frank. The episode was noted for its nostalgia but criticized for repetitive dynamics and a lackluster execution .
The Gang Goes to a Dog Track (Episode 5)
Frank takes the Gang to a dog racing venue, where Dennis and Dee gamble away their money and self-respect, while Mac and Charlie explore a “raw dog” lifestyle. The episode delves into dark and uncomfortable territory, including animal-based humor and a shocking ending. Reviews were mixed, with some appreciating its darkness and others finding it offensive or cringe-worthy .
Thought Leadership: A Corporate Conversation (Episode 4)
This episode parodies Succession, with the Gang using corporate jargon to avoid a public relations nightmare. It sets up the crossover with Abbott Elementary but was criticized for its over-reliance on business themes and predictable plot. Many reviewers considered it the weakest episode of the season, with one calling it “the worst episode of the season for me” .
Credits: Ronit J Author, AV Club
