Taylor Sheridan has built a television empire over the past several years. Starting with Yellowstone in 2018, he created a world that now spans multiple shows, timelines, and genres. From Western dramas to spy thrillers and reality competitions, his name has become a mark of quality for streaming audiences.
Sheridan began as an actor before moving into writing. He wrote films like Sicario, Hell or High Water, and Wind River before turning his attention to television. Today, he runs multiple shows at once, and each one brings in millions of viewers. With new series like The Madison and Marshals just released, here is a complete ranking of every Taylor Sheridan TV show based on IMDb ratings.
1883 (IMDb: 8.7)
The highest-rated show in Sheridan’s catalog is 1883, the Yellowstone prequel that follows the Dutton family’s difficult journey west. The series stars Sam Elliott, Tim McGraw, and Faith Hill as pioneers traveling through the untamed American frontier. Isabel May narrates the story as Elsa Dutton, whose voice guides viewers through the brutal journey.
The show ran for one season of 10 episodes, ending in February 2022. Critics and audiences praised it for its raw storytelling and historical detail. Sheridan called it a “10-hour movie,” and it remains the most critically loved entry in his universe. Many viewers consider it the best thing he has made, with an IMDb score of 8.7.
Yellowstone (IMDb: 8.6)
The show that started it all, Yellowstone, holds an 8.6 rating on IMDb. Kevin Costner led the series as John Dutton, the patriarch of a Montana ranching family fighting to keep their land. The modern Western ran for five seasons from 2018 to 2024 and became a cultural phenomenon.
At its peak, the show drew over 16 million viewers for its season 5 premiere. It launched the entire Sheridan-verse and proved that Western stories could still draw massive audiences. The series also stars Luke Grimes, Kelly Reilly, and Cole Hauser, who will continue their characters in upcoming spin-offs.
1923 (IMDb: 8.3)
1923 follows the Dutton family during the early 20th century, dealing with Prohibition, drought, and the Great Depression. Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren star as Jacob and Cara Dutton, leading the family through difficult times.
The second and final season aired in early 2025, ending on April 6, 2025. The show earned an 8.3 IMDb rating and also features Brandon Sklenar, Julia Schlaepfer, and Aminah Nieves. Unlike other shows in the universe, 1923 explored settings beyond Montana, including Africa and Europe.
Landman (IMDb: 8.2)
Landman moves away from the Yellowstone universe to focus on the oil industry in West Texas. Billy Bob Thornton stars as Tommy Norris, a fixer who handles problems for an oil company. The show also features Demi Moore, Jon Hamm, and Ali Larter.
The first season released in late 2024, and the show was quickly renewed for a second season. It currently holds an 8.2 IMDb rating. Season 2 is now filming, with Sam Elliott joining the cast as a series regular. The show has become one of Paramount Plus’s most-watched series, with Season 2 pulling 9.2 million views in its opening days.
Mayor of Kingstown (IMDb: 8.2)
Mayor of Kingstown stars Jeremy Renner as Mike McLusky, a man who acts as a power broker between criminals, police, and prison officials in a Michigan town dominated by correctional facilities. The show takes a harsh look at the prison system and does not offer easy answers.
The series has run for four seasons, with the fourth arriving in October 2025. In January 2026, Paramount renewed it for a fifth and final season. It shares the 8.2 rating with Landman and has built a loyal audience that appreciates its dark, grounded storytelling.
The Madison (IMDb: 8.0)
The Madison is the newest entry in the Sheridan-verse. It stars Michelle Pfeiffer and Kurt Russell in a story about a New York City family who moves to Montana after dealing with grief. The show premiered on March 14, 2026, with its first three episodes. The remaining three episodes dropped on March 21.
Paramount+ announced that The Madison earned 8 million views globally in its first 10 days, making it the most-watched first season of any Sheridan series. It has already been renewed for a second season. The show holds an 8.0 IMDb rating based on early audience scores. The cast also includes Patrick J. Adams, Beau Garrett, and Matthew Fox.
Tulsa King (IMDb: 7.9)
Tulsa King gives Sylvester Stallone his first leading TV role. He plays Dwight Manfredi, a mobster who starts a new criminal operation in Tulsa, Oklahoma, after spending 25 years in prison. The show blends crime drama with humor as Dwight builds his empire from the ground up.
The series holds a 7.9 IMDb rating and was created by Sheridan along with Terence Winter. It has been successful enough to spawn a spin-off starring Samuel L. Jackson. Stallone’s performance earned him a Primetime Creative Arts Emmy nomination in 2023.
Lioness (IMDb: 7.8)
Lioness, also known as Special Ops: Lioness, follows Zoe Saldaña as a CIA officer who runs a program that places female operatives close to high-value targets. The show also stars Nicole Kidman and Morgan Freeman.
The first season came out in 2023, followed by a second season in October 2024. The series has a 7.8 IMDb rating. While it is one of Sheridan’s lower-rated scripted shows, it still drew strong viewership on Paramount+. A third season was announced in 2025.
Lawmen: Bass Reeves (IMDb: 7.3)
Lawmen: Bass Reeves tells the true story of the first Black U.S. Marshal west of the Mississippi. David Oyelowo plays the lead role, with supporting turns from Dennis Quaid, Donald Sutherland, and Barry Pepper.
The show is set in the Yellowstone universe but focuses on a historical figure rather than the Dutton family. It earned a 7.3 IMDb rating and received positive reviews for Oyelowo’s performance. Sheridan serves as executive producer, with Chad Feehan as showrunner.
The Last Cowboy (IMDb: 6.6)
The Last Cowboy is a documentary competition series that follows horse trainers as they prepare for a $1 million reining event. It is Sheridan’s only unscripted show and has run for six seasons on CMT and Paramount.
The show holds a 6.6 IMDb rating. It fits within Sheridan’s focus on Western culture and shows a different side of his storytelling abilities. Real-life trainers compete in each season, and the series has built a loyal fan base among rodeo and horse training enthusiasts.
Marshals (IMDb: 6.0)
Marshals is the lowest-rated Sheridan show. It follows Luke Grimes as Kayce Dutton, who becomes a U.S. Marshal after the events of Yellowstone. The show premiered on CBS in March 2026.
Critics gave it a 44% score on Rotten Tomatoes, and audience ratings have been mixed. It currently holds a 6.0 on IMDb. Despite the low reviews, the show drew 9.52 million viewers for its premiere on CBS. The cast includes Logan Marshall-Green, Arielle Kebbel, and Gil Birmingham.
Also Read: Daredevil: Born Again Season 2 Character Guide – Which Heroes and Villains Match the Comics?
For more updates on Taylor Sheridan shows, streaming news, and TV rankings, keep reading VvipTimes for the latest entertainment coverage.
