The wait for a full Supernatural reunion on The Boys finally paid off in a way nobody expected. Prime Video released deleted footage from Season 5 that shows Jensen Ackles, Jared Padalecki, and Misha Collins slipping back into their old roles instead of playing their new characters. The alternate take transforms a simple crossover into something much more personal for fans who followed the Winchester brothers for 15 seasons.
The footage dropped on May 9, 2026, and within hours, social media exploded with reactions. Showrunner Eric Kripke, who created both series, gave viewers a hidden gem that feels less like a deleted scene and more like a love letter to the Supernatural fandom.
The Deleted Scene Turns Soldier Boy Back Into Dean Winchester
In the official Season 5 Episode 5 titled “One-Shots,” Padalecki’s Mister Marathon and Collins’ Malchemical appear briefly alongside Ackles’ Soldier Boy. The scene works within The Boys’ dark, violent world. But the newly released alternate cut throws all that out the window.
The deleted footage shows Padalecki and Collins acting exactly like Sam Winchester and Castiel. They try to convince Dean to turn against Homelander by listing every terrible thing the villain has done. The dialogue includes direct references to Busty Asian Beauties, Dean’s favorite magazine from the original show. One line even has Padalecki shouting, “He’s taking Chuck’s name in vain!”
Fans on Reddit and X pointed out that the energy in this version feels nothing like The Boys. It feels like watching Supernatural Season 16 where the Winchesters accidentally walked onto the wrong set. The chemistry between the three actors remains as natural as it was when the show ended in 2020.
Also Read:
Eric Kripke Knew Exactly What Fans Wanted From This Reunion
Kripke spent years building Supernatural into a cultural phenomenon. He moved on to create The Boys, but he never forgot the fanbase that supported him. Bringing Ackles onto the show as Soldier Boy in Season 3 marked the first big reunion. Adding Padalecki and Collins in Season 5 completed the picture.
In interviews, the three actors admitted they filmed multiple takes of their scene together. One specific take had them performing entirely as Sam, Dean, and Castiel. Collins confirmed this during a Supernatural 20th anniversary interview, saying he immediately fell back into Castiel’s voice and mannerisms. Padalecki joked that he forgot how to act, while Ackles teased him back, saying he was never sure Padalecki knew how in the first place.
Ackles admitted in a separate interview that he doubted the scene would ever make it into the final cut. He thought the idea might end up as just a test scene that never aired. But Kripke found a way to make it work within the actual story of The Boys.
“When I heard the idea, I thought: ‘Okay, is this just going to be a test scene that doesn’t even make the final cut? Is it going to be part of the actual series or is this really going to connect with the story?’ But they found a way to fit it into the narrative in a way that made sense. I was happy they found a way to use both Jared and Misha.” — Jensen Ackles
The On-Set Accident That Almost Ruined the Reunion
Filming the reunion scene was not without its dangers. Ackles recently revealed that he accidentally punched Padalecki in the face while shooting a fight sequence. The Soldier Boy costume restricted his movement more than he expected. When he threw a punch, his aim was off, and he connected with Padalecki’s nose.
Despite the hit, Padalecki did not stop the scene. He kept going until the director called cut. Crew members checked on him, and thankfully, there was no serious injury. Ackles described the moment as an honest mistake caused by the bulky superhero suit he wears on the show.
The accident did not stop the two actors from joking about it afterward. Their off-screen friendship, built over 15 years of working together, made the moment easier to laugh about. Fans who watched the deleted scene noted that the chemistry in the footage feels so real because these three people genuinely like each other.
Why This Deleted Footage Matters More Than a Gag Reel
Most deleted scenes offer small moments that did not fit the pacing of an episode. This one is different. It shows that Kripke and the cast knew the reunion would mean something deeper to longtime viewers. Rather than ignoring the actors’ history, the alternate take embraces it fully.
The Boys has always played with fan culture. The show satirizes superhero fandom while also participating in it. This deleted scene takes that idea one step further. It gives fans the exact thing they wanted to see while also winking at how ridiculous it is to have Sam, Dean, and Castiel show up in a show about corrupt superheroes.
Padalecki and Collins both shared the deleted footage on their social media accounts. Their posts received hundreds of thousands of likes within the first day. Comments flooded in from fans who grew up watching Supernatural and now watch The Boys as adults.
The response proved that the Supernatural fandom remains active and engaged years after the series finale. The show ended in 2020, but its audience never truly left. They just moved to whatever Kripke did next.
What Happens to Soldier Boy and the Others Now
Season 5 of The Boys marks the final season. The show is building toward an explosive conclusion that will determine the fate of Butcher, Homelander, and everyone caught between them. Soldier Boy remains a wild card in the story. His return in Season 3 changed the balance of power, and his role in the final episodes could determine who wins.
Mister Marathon and Malchemical have smaller roles in the grand scheme of The Boys’ story. But their presence alongside Soldier Boy gave fans a moment of joy before the inevitable bloodshed that this show always delivers.
The deleted scene serves as a reminder that even in a world full of gore, satire, and dark humor, there is still room for a little bit of heart. Kripke built two shows about monsters, heroes, and family. The fact that he found a way to connect them after all these years shows how much he values the people who made both shows possible.
Also Read: The Crash Documentary on Netflix: Release Date, Shocking True Story and Everything You Need to Know
Keep up with more breaking entertainment news and exclusive content only on VvipTimes.
