The Winter 2026 anime season brought another villainess story to screens, but critics are not impressed. Richard Eisenbeis of Anime News Network gave the series a D+ overall grade, pointing to major issues with the animation quality and the main characters. The show finished its 12-episode run with viewers and critics agreeing on its biggest flaws.
Critics Call The Anime A “Female Disempowerment Fantasy”
The story follows Tiararose Lapis Clementille, voiced by Mai Fuchigami, who remembers her past life just days before her graduation. She realizes she is the villainess in an otome game called Lapis Lazuli Ring. After the prince calls off their engagement in public, Aquasteed Marineforest (Yuuichirou Umehara), the prince from a neighboring kingdom, proposes to her on the spot.
The review describes this setup as the opposite of male empowerment fantasies. Tiara has very little control over her own story. Her only magic power is making sweets that taste good. The men around her, either Aqua or Keith the Fairy King, always step in to save her. Most problems Tiara faces exist only inside her head, coming from her fears about the game’s bad ending.
“Tiara has very little agency in her own story. She is the damsel in distress rather than the hero.”
One forum user on Anime News Network pointed out another issue with the main character. They wrote that Mai Fuchigami “came up with a rather whiny vocal quality for Tiara that grated on my nerves after a while.” This made the already passive character harder to watch for some viewers.
Side Characters Steal The Show From The Leads
While Tiara and Aqua fail to impress, the side characters offer something more interesting. Akari and Icilla, the heroines from the otome game, provide the show’s most captivating moments. Akari also reincarnated into this world but still sees everything as a game. She knows exactly what to say and do to win over her romantic targets.
Icilla goes through the most complete character arc. The review explains that Tiara accidentally steals Icilla’s planned character development. Icilla was supposed to learn about love through a relationship with Aqua, but that never happens. When feelings do wake up inside her, she does not know how to handle them. In the final arc, she falls into depression and uses a love potion to get what she wants, even knowing the love is fake and that she is hurting Tiara.
A reviewer on Anime-Kun shared similar feelings about the boring leads but interesting antagonists. They wrote in French that all the moments with the two main characters together are the worst parts to watch. The dialogue repeats the same “I love you” lines around 10 times per episode, which they found awkward and lacking depth. They gave the show a 3 out of 10.
Animation Quality Becomes The Show’s Biggest Problem
The review identifies the animation as the real low point. Action scenes suffer from wrong proportions, missing details, and stiff movement. Even non-action scenes use still frames with very little motion whenever possible. The visuals do not look good even during the most important scenes, creating a clash with the above-average music.
The opening and ending songs feature male and female duets that fit the romance-focused series well. The music received a C+ grade, making it the highest scored category in the review. Art got a C- and animation got a D.
One MyShows.me user commented on the failed tension in the show. They wrote that the creators try to build tension but it does not work. They also pointed out how Tiara worries too much and Aqua needs to communicate better. Another user called this “one of the weakest representatives of the villainess subgenre” in terms of plot, characters, and chemistry between the main couple.
A viewer on the Anime News Network forum said they dropped the show about halfway through. They could not take any more picnics, tea parties, and sweet fests where conversations only talked about how delicious the tea and sweets were. Every time the story looked like it might start moving, it stopped for more tea and sweets.
Also Read:
English Dub And Streaming Details For Global Audiences
Crunchyroll streamed the series exclusively starting January 11, 2026. The English dub arrived on January 25, 2026. The English cast includes Kate Bristol as Tiararose, Aaron Campbell as Aquasteed, Conner Allison as Hartknights, and Kara Edwards as Akari.
The series comes from Studio Deen with Takayuki Hamana as director. The original light novels by Puni-chan began as a web novel in 2016, making this one of the earlier villainess stories before the subgenre became popular. The anime took nearly ten years to happen, even as newer titles inspired by it already made it to television.
Also Read: Blake Lively Drags Justin Baldoni Back to Court Seeking Legal Fees After Settlement
Stay updated with more anime reviews and entertainment news on VvipTimes.
