Will Smith’s first album in 20 years, Based on a True Story, has sparked controversy—not for its music but for its lyrical references to the infamous 2022 Oscars slap. Comedian Tony Rock, brother of Chris Rock, publicly criticized the album, calling it “sh***y” and accusing Smith of lacking fresh material by revisiting the scandal. Despite high-profile collaborations and a major promotional push, the album has struggled commercially, failing to chart on the *Billboard 200* and selling just 268 copies in the UK during its first week .
Tony Rock’s Harsh Criticism
Tony Rock, who has openly admitted he hasn’t listened to the album, didn’t hold back in his assessment. Speaking to TMZ Hip Hop, he dismissed the project, saying:
“I haven’t heard ANY of Will’s new album, but if he’s using ‘The Slap’ to sell it, that tells me he ain’t got s* to say.”**
He further mocked Smith’s decision to address the incident, adding:
“I’ve tried to let the issue go, but I’m appalled The Fresh Prince would refresh the beef by attempting to sell off raps laced in doo-doo.”
Tony’s comments highlight lingering tensions from the 2022 Oscars, where Smith stormed the stage and slapped Chris Rock after a joke about Jada Pinkett Smith’s alopecia. The fallout led to Smith’s 10-year ban from Academy events and widespread backlash .
Will Smith’s Album and Its Slap References
Based on a True Story doesn’t shy away from the controversy. The opening track, “Int. Barbershop – Day”, features a dialogue between Smith, DJ Jazzy Jeff, and comedian B. Simone, where they debate his public image post-slap. Lyrics include:
“Will Smith is cancelled.” “Who the f* Will Smith think he is?”** “I ain’t never going to forgive him for that s* he did.”**
Another track, “You Lookin’ for Me?”, sees Smith defiantly rapping:
“Took a lot, I’m back on top / Y’all gon’ have to get acclimated / Won’t stop, my s* still hot / Even though I won’t get nominated.”**
The album also revisits Smith’s viral Oscars moment with the line:
“Him and Jada both crazy girl, what you talkin’ bout? / You better keep his wife’s name out of your mouth.”
Commercial Struggles and Tour Plans
Despite features from Big Sean, Jaden Smith, and Teyana Taylor, the album has underperformed. In the UK, it sold just 36 digital downloads in its first week, a stark contrast to Smith’s past successes like Big Willie Style and Lost and Found .
Smith has announced a headline tour in the UK and Europe, his first solo concert series. However, fans have noted the venues are surprisingly small, with most holding under 5,000 people, and major cities like Birmingham and Glasgow are skipped .
Public and Industry Reactions
While some critics see the album as Smith’s attempt at redemption, others, like Tony Rock, view it as a desperate move. Smith has defended the project, saying in interviews that the past few years led to a “deep exploration” of his identity, calling this phase his “greatest artistic creative period” .
