Upasana Singh and Nagma Morarji Claim CINTAA Victory After High Court Contempt Notice

Upasana Singh and Nagma Morarji Claim CINTAA Victory After High Court Contempt Notice

IST

4โ€“5 minutes

Read

Share This Article via:-

The legal fight inside the Cine and TV Artistesโ€™ Association is not a simple story of one faction beating another. The Bombay High Courtโ€™s October 22 order did not declare Upasana Singh the winner of a disputed election. It issued a contempt show-cause notice to the rival faction led by Poonam Dhillon and Padmini Kolhapure, restrained that faction from acting on its own October 20 poll results, and left the underlying question of who controls CINTAA to be argued another day.

That distinction matters because Upasana and treasurer Nagma Morarji held a press conference in Mumbai on October 28 and framed the court developments as a clean vindication. โ€œIf we are truthful, we ought to win, and we have won,โ€ Upasana said, invoking Satyameva Jayate. The court record is more procedural than that quote suggests, but the procedural wins are real, and they have given Upasanaโ€™s committee physical control of the associationโ€™s office since October 27.

What the High Court Actually Did

The sequence runs from a September 12 election to an October 20 counter-election. Upasana topped the September 12 poll conducted under the supervision of the Federation of Western India Cine Employees, securing 360 votes against Sahila Chadhaโ€™s 357. The Dhillon-Kolhapure faction challenged that process and held its own election on October 20, where Kolhapure emerged with 604 votes.

Advertisements

FWICE then filed a contempt petition. It argued that the October 20 poll violated the High Courtโ€™s September 11 and October 19 directions, which had asked parties to refrain from steps that could affect the courtโ€™s oversight while a motion remained pending. Justice Aarti Sathe found a prima facie case of wilful disobedience and breach of an undertaking, issued notice under Rule 9(1) of the Contempt of Courts (Bombay High Court) Rules, 1994, and directed the faction not to give effect to the October 20 results.

The matter returns to the Bombay High Court on November 18, when the Dhillon-Kolhapure faction must explain why contempt proceedings should not be initiated. That hearing is the next real fork in the dispute. Upasanaโ€™s claim of victory rests on an interim order, not a final judgment on the validity of either election.

The Dindoshi Court Layer

Upasana also cited the Dindoshi Court, which she said ruled in her factionโ€™s favour. The City Civil Court at Dindoshi rejected the rival factionโ€™s plea for interim relief on October 21, a day before the High Court contempt notice. CINTAAโ€™s lawyer Suvigya Vidyarthi, representing the Dhillon faction, has disputed the broader reading of that order. He told the Times of India that no court had ruled CINTAA could not conduct its own elections, and that the question of whether FWICE had authority to run a rival poll would be decided only after a full trial.

That legal caveat does not erase the practical reality. Upasanaโ€™s committee took charge on October 27 with a hawan, and she says the priority now is member welfare and recovering association funds.

The Money Allegation Behind the Fight

The governance dispute is not only about election paperwork. Upasana alleged at the press conference that fixed deposits worth โ‚น73 lakh were broken and transferred to an account at Punjab National Bank, after four other banks declined to allow free operation of the accounts. She also claimed CINTAAโ€™s constitutional requirement that 20 per cent of funds be spent on artistsโ€™ welfare had been ignored, and that artists struggling with school fees and medical bills were turned away while money went to press conferences.

Nagma framed the financial question as an institutional one. โ€œThe funds, assets, and records that have accumulated here since 1958 belong solely and exclusively to the association and its artists,โ€ she said. โ€œThey are not anyoneโ€™s personal propertyโ€. The Dhillon-Kolhapure faction has not responded to these specific allegations in the court record cited here. The contempt hearing on November 18 will not resolve the money claims; it will address whether the October 20 election breached court directions.

What โ€œTruthfulโ€ Means in a Court File

Upasanaโ€™s soundbite is effective, but the legal outcome she is claiming depends on a narrower point: the rival faction went ahead with an election after the High Court had asked for restraint. That is why the contempt notice, not a declaration of presidency, is the centre of the story. If the High Court presses the contempt case on November 18, the Dhillon-Kolhapure faction faces an explanation burden. If the court accepts its response, the fight over election authority returns to the City Civil Court for a fuller trial.

For now, Upasana controls the office and the narrative. Nagma controls the treasurerโ€™s argument that the associationโ€™s assets belong to the institution, not to any faction. The November 18 hearing will test whether the court sees the October 20 poll as a procedural breach or something more serious. That is the detail the โ€œtruthfulโ€ framing leaves out, and it is the detail that will decide what actually happens next.

Also Read: Deepak Parashar Quits CINTAA Citing Humiliation, Alleges Misbehavior by Poonam Dhillon

the CINTAA row is a reminder that in entertainment-union disputes, control of the office and control of the court calendar are two different victories โ€” and only one of them has been settled.

Keep checking VVIPTimes.


Advertisements


Advertisements

Leave a reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Advertisements
Advertisements
Advertisements

Trending in Hollywood

Advertisements

Trending in K-Pop/Dramas ๐Ÿ”—

Advertisements

Trending in TV Series ๐Ÿ”—

Advertisements

Trending in Bollywood/South-Indian

Advertisements

Browse Topics

ABC ACTION MOVIE ACTION SERIES ADOR aespa A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms ANIMATED SERIES ANIME Antony Starr apple tv APPLE TV PLUS BLACKPINK Bollywood Bridgerton BTS BTS V BYEON WOO SEOK C-Drama CBS Charlie Cox COMEDY SERIES CONNOR STORRIE CRIME DRAMA CRIME SERIES Crunchyroll DAREDEVIL BORN AGAIN Disney Plus DRAMA SERIES FANTASY SERIES G-DRAGON Game of Thrones HAN SO HEE HBO HBO Max HEATED RIVALRY Hollywood HORROR SERIES House of the Dragon HUDSON WILLIAMS Hulu HYBE IT WELCOME TO DERRY IU Jacob Elordi JAMES GUNN JENNIE Jensen Ackles JISOO JUNGKOOK K-DRAMA K-POP Karl Urban KIM JI WON KIM SOO HYUN LEE MIN HO LISA MANGA Marvel Marvel Studios MCU MEDICAL DRAMA Millie Bobby Brown MIN HEE JIN MOVIE NBC NETFLIX NEWJEANS Noah Wyle One Piece Paramount Plus PARK BO GUM Peacock PERIOD DRAMA Pluribus Prime Video QUEEN OF TEARS Reality TV RHEA SEEHORN ROMANCE SERIES ROMANTIC COMEDY ROSร‰ Ryan Murphy SCI-FI SERIES SCI FI SERIES SEVENTEEN Soap Opera Stephen King STRANGER THINGS SUGA SUPERHERO SERIES Sydney Sweeney Taylor Sheridan TAYLOR SWIFT The Boys The Pitt THRILLER SERIES Tom Holland TRUE CRIME VINCE GILLIGAN Zendaya