On January 24, BLACKPINK’s Jennie released her latest track, “Zen,” ahead of her upcoming solo album, Ruby. The track’s visuals stood out, marking a shift from her previous single, “Mantra.” While many praised the new visuals, they soon became the center of plagiarism allegations, sparking a larger debate on the creativity behind music videos in the K-pop industry.
Accusations of Plagiarism
Jennie faced accusations of copying XG’s “Howling” in terms of the videoโs aesthetics and style. The visuals in both music videos bore notable similarities, with fans pointing out comparable imagery, editing styles, and even accessories featured in the two videos. These observations quickly fueled online discussions, with many accusing Jennie of borrowing ideas from another artist’s work.
However, the situation took a turn when netizens uncovered that both “Zen” and “Howling” were directed by Choi Gi Seok. Choi, a well-known director in the K-pop scene, shared credits for both videos on his Instagram, which led many to believe the similarities in the visuals were due to the directorโs creative choices rather than plagiarism by Jennie herself.
The Role of Director Choi Gi Seok
Despite the allegations against Jennie being largely disproven, the focus shifted to Choi Gi Seok. Fans and critics alike expressed their frustration with the director for reusing similar concepts in different projects. The accusations grew as it became apparent that Choi had incorporated strikingly similar visual elements across multiple music videos, leading many to question whether his approach lacked originality.
ALSO READ: Marry My Husbandโs Gong Min Jung Shares First Pictures of Daughter with Husband Jang Jae Ho
Critics argued that reusing the same concepts in different projects could stifle creativity in the K-pop industry, particularly when such similarities were present across notable artists. In this case, the same director was behind both the “Zen” and “Howling” videos, prompting discussions about whether there was a lack of diversity in the creative direction for these major K-pop acts.
Reactions from Fans and Industry Experts
The debate surrounding the similarity of the music videos ignited broader discussions within the K-pop community. Some defended Jennie, stating that she should not be held responsible for a director’s creative choices. Others, however, called for more accountability from both artists and directors, urging for clearer boundaries between distinct visual concepts in the music video production process.
Industry experts weighed in, with some highlighting the blurred lines between influence and imitation in the visual arts. While many acknowledge that artists and directors often draw inspiration from previous works, there is a fine line between homage and direct copying, which fans and critics are increasingly sensitive to.
ALSO READ: Zhao Lusi Makes Emotional Return to Public Life After Health Struggles and Allegations
Although the plagiarism allegations against Jennie have been largely cleared, the incident has raised critical questions about the role of creative directors in the K-pop industry. With similar visuals appearing in multiple high-profile music videos, fans are now calling for greater originality and fresh concepts in the visual production of K-pop music videos.
For more updates on BLACKPINK and Jennie’s solo career, stay tuned to Vviptimes.
