If you are watching the new AMC show Talamasca: The Secret Order, you already know about secret societies, hidden worlds, and the agents who keep the balance between humans and the supernatural. The show, based on Anne Rice’s novels, premiered this October and follows members of a mysterious organization as they track powerful beings . For those who enjoy the mix of spy intrigue and occult horror, there is a whole world of similar shows waiting. From werewolf battles in college to vampire politics in Louisiana, these five series are perfect for your next watch.
Grimm: A Detective’s Guide To Monster-Hunting
A great choice for fans of the investigative side of Talamasca is Grimm. The show premiered on NBC in 2011 and is available to stream on Peacock and Amazon Prime Video . It follows Nick Burkhardt, a Portland detective who discovers he is a “Grimm,” a person with the ability to see supernatural creatures, or “Wesen,” living hidden among humans .
Much like the Talamasca agents who observe and document, Nick must learn to navigate this secret world while solving weekly cases. The show successfully mixes police procedural elements with a rich, ongoing mythology about monsters and ancient families. It ran for six seasons, giving viewers plenty of time to get invested in its unique world of rules, alliances, and threats .
The Order: Secret Societies And Campus Warfare
For a story that centers even more directly on a hidden magical organization, try The Order. This Netflix original series launched in 2019 and ran for two seasons . It follows Jack Morton, a college student who joins a secret magical society called the Hermetic Order of the Blue Rose to uncover truths about his family’s past .
He quickly finds himself in the middle of a dangerous war between the magic-users of the Order and a rival group of werewolves. The series captures the same vibe of formal initiations, ancient rituals, and dark secrets that define the Talamasca . With its setting on a university campus, it adds a younger, modern energy to the classic secret society story, exploring themes of power, loyalty, and legacy.
Chilling Adventures of Sabrina: A Witch’s Dual Life
If the witch-centric elements of Talamasca interest you, Chilling Adventures of Sabrina is an essential watch. This darker take on the classic Archie Comics character arrived on Netflix in 2018 . It stars Kiernan Shipka as Sabrina Spellman, a half-witch, half-mortal teenager who must reconcile her normal life in the mortal world with her dark destiny in the Church of Night, a satanic coven.
The series is steeped in occult themes, from blood magic and pagan rituals to deals with literal demons. It explores the high cost of power and the burden of secret knowledge, much like the struggles faced by characters in the world of Anne Rice . The show’s rich, gothic atmosphere and its focus on a hidden, rule-bound supernatural community make it a compelling companion to Talamasca.
True Blood: Vampires Out Of The Coffin
To dive into a fully realized world where the supernatural is public, True Blood is a landmark series. It first aired on HBO in 2008 and is available to stream on HBO Max . Set in a small Louisiana town, the show imagines a world where vampires have “come out of the coffin” thanks to the invention of synthetic blood .
The story follows Sookie Stackhouse, a waitress with psychic abilities, and her relationships with vampires, werewolves, and other beings. Beyond its central romance, the show is a deep exploration of prejudice, identity, and integration, using supernatural creatures as a metaphor for real-world social issues . Its Southern gothic setting, complex politics, and large ensemble cast create a rich, long-running narrative that fans of Talamasca‘s world-building will appreciate.
Also Read:
Penny Dreadful: A Gothic Masterpiece Of Monsters
For those who love the classic, literary horror roots of Anne Rice’s universe, Penny Dreadful is a perfect match. This series aired on Showtime beginning in 2014 and is available on Showtime and Amazon Prime Video . Set in Victorian London, it brilliantly weaves together characters from 19th-century Gothic literature, including Dr. Frankenstein, Dorian Gray, and figures from Dracula .
At its heart is Vanessa Ives, played by Eva Green, a woman grappling with powerful supernatural possession . The show is celebrated for its stunning atmosphere, psychological depth, and slow-burn terror. Like Talamasca, it deals with secretive organizations, ancient evils, and characters who stand on the line between human and monster . Its commitment to a dark, sumptuous, and character-driven story makes it one of the most respected shows in the genre.
Also Read: Dancing With The Stars Host Julianne Hough: From Teen Pro To Guiding “Big Sister” In The Ballroom
