A frozen lake, a dead queen bee, and a twin sister playing detective. That is the setup for Student of the Year: After Dark, a six-episode series that takes Karan Johar’s glossy campus franchise and drops it into a murder mystery. The show premiered on November 13, 2026, on JioHotstar in India, and is also available on Hulu in the US and STARZPLAY in select regions. Headlined by Shanaya Kapoor in a double role, the series has drawn sharply divided reviews and a noisy reaction on social media.
What the Show Is About
The story returns to St. Teresa’s Heritage School, the same elite campus from the 2012 film. Aayesha Malik, the school’s most popular student, is found dead in a frozen lake. Her estranged twin sister, Aditi, enrols at the school to find out what really happened. Her search leads her to an underground competition also called Student of the Year — a secret game with masked conductors, high stakes, and a promise of entry into a powerful circle.
The series is produced by Dharmatic Entertainment, with Karan Johar, Adar Poonawalla, and Apoorva Mehta as producers. Reema Maya (also known as Reema Sengupta) directs and co-writes with Debashish Irengbam. The six episodes run between 29 and 55 minutes each, for a total runtime of roughly 230 minutes.
Shanaya Kapoor Plays Two Very Different Sisters
Kapoor’s dual role is the show’s central attraction. Aayesha is the confident, popular face of the campus. Aditi is guarded, grieving, and driven by suspicion. Most reviewers agree that Kapoor makes a visible effort to separate the two characters.
Filmfare noted that Kapoor “deserves credit for making an impression” and that her portrayal of Aditi, in particular, carries emotional weight. Times of India called her work “a sincere attempt” and said her Aditi is more convincing in moments of grief and loneliness. Pinkvilla described her performance as “surprisingly assured” across both roles.
The supporting cast includes Divik Sharma as Sid, Manya Grover as Tara, Abhinav Singh as Rehaan, Deeya Damini as Babydoll, and Adi Malik. Veteran actors Sheeba Chaddha, Khalid Siddiqui, Neeraj Kabi, and Vivek Gomber appear in adult roles.
Direction and Atmosphere Work Better Than the Script
Reema Maya brings a clear visual language to the series. Pinkvilla praised the “moody cinematography, stylish production design, and gothic aesthetics,” and Zee News highlighted the background score by Night Song and Shalom Benjamin for adding tension. The show’s music, a mix of English, Hindi, and Punjabi tracks, comes from Achint Thakkar, Chaar Diwaari, Ninja, and Shirish Prakash Singh.
The atmosphere is consistently dark. St. Teresa’s is no longer a place of designer wardrobes and dance numbers. It is a campus of hidden corridors, secret games, and uncomfortable silences. That tonal shift is the show’s biggest risk, and it is also the part that works most often.
Karan Johar framed the change in a statement shared at the announcement:
“We began this franchise with big dreams in 2012 and now we’re breaking every rule we set.”
Reema Maya described her approach in simpler terms:
“It is Student Of The Year, stripped to its bones and reimagined as a thriller competition web series.”
The Writing Is the Weak Point
Most negative reviews point to the same problem: the story tries to do too much and loses control of its own mystery. Filmfare called the writing “the biggest problem” and said the twists often “seem designed to confuse rather than to intrigue.” The review added that the non-linear narrative, multiple subplots, voiceovers, and explanatory intertitles make an already complicated story harder to follow.
Telegraph India wrote that “the biggest casualty is the storytelling,” noting that the series introduces themes of grief, trauma, and parental pressure but repeatedly pushes them aside for another twist. Cinema Express was harsher, calling the show “a bad cocktail mix of 13 Reasons Why and Squid Game” and saying it feels “stretched, exasperating and plain snooze-worthy.”
The comparisons to other shows come up in almost every review. Elite, Squid Game, Riverdale, Pretty Little Liars, and 13 Reasons Why are the most frequent reference points. The underground competition, with its masked figures and high-stakes games, invites the Squid Game comparison directly. The privileged-school setting and murder plot echo Elite. The question reviewers keep asking is whether the show borrows those elements without giving them a fresh identity.
Critical Reception: A Wide Spread of Scores
Review scores range from very positive to very negative, which is unusual for a franchise title.
- Filmfare: 2.5/5 — praised Kapoor, criticised the writing and pacing
- Times of India: mixed — called the change in genre “refreshing” but said the execution “falls short of its potential”
- Pinkvilla: 3/5 — liked the tone and Kapoor’s performance, pointed to “predictable thriller tropes” and “underdeveloped supporting characters”
- Cinema Express: 1.5/5 — called it “mind-numbingly unimaginative” and “plain boring at instances”
- Zee News: 4.5/5 — called it “an addictive campus mystery” and praised Kapoor’s “confident performance”
- Bollywood Hungama: positive — described it as “a stylish and intriguing thriller” with Kapoor’s performance and the background score as its strongest points
That spread tells you something important: the show lands differently depending on what you want from it. Viewers looking for a moody, stylish campus thriller with a strong central performance are more likely to enjoy it. Viewers looking for a tight, coherent murder mystery are more likely to be frustrated.
What Viewers Are Saying
Social media reaction has been just as divided as the critic scores. On X, some users praised the darker tone and the atmosphere. Others mocked the show’s resemblance to Squid Game and complained about the pacing and dialogue.
ThePrint collected a range of reactions. One X user called the show “surprisingly very enjoyable” and described it as “very Riverdale-core.” Another wrote: “Bro this sasta squidgame show makes zero sense.” A third viewer gave it 3.5/5 and said the plot was similar to other shows but still enjoyable.
On Reddit, reactions followed the same pattern. Some users were glad to see an Indian high-school drama, noting that the genre is rare in Indian streaming. Others found the script and dialogues “corny” and said the games felt “lazily put together.”
The mixed response does not mean the show failed to find an audience. It means the show is polarising in a way that franchise titles usually are not. The original Student of the Year was a glossy, low-stakes romance. After Dark asks viewers to accept a version of the same campus where the competition can get someone killed. That is a big ask, and the show does not always earn it.
Related Stories
Where to Watch
All six episodes of Student of the Year: After Dark are streaming now.
- India: JioHotstar
- United States: Hulu (through JioHotstar’s content offering)
- Select international markets: STARZPLAY
A second season has not been announced. The finale leaves several character threads open, but there is no official confirmation of a follow-up.
For more reviews and streaming updates, keep reading VvipTimes.







































Leave a Reply