Dominic McLaughlin is 12 years old. He has not yet appeared in a single episode of HBO’s Harry Potter series. And yet, his teeth have become the subject of a heated online debate.
A viral post on X compared the young actor’s smile to that of Daniel Radcliffe, who played Harry Potter in the original films. The critique argued that a child should have a child’s smile. The response from Harry Potter fans was swift, and it was not kind to the critic.
The back-and-forth arrived just days after HBO released a 90-second clip from the series, showing the start-of-term banquet at Hogwarts. That clip already had fans split over the show’s lighting and color. The teeth debate added a sharper, more personal edge to the conversation.
What Sparked the Teeth Debate
On November 16, 2026, X user Tyler Dean McDowell posted side-by-side images of Daniel Radcliffe and Dominic McLaughlin smiling. The post focused on McLaughlin’s teeth, calling them unusually perfect for an 11-year-old.
“It’s the teeth, man. An 11-year-old should have an 11-year-old’s smile. But let me be clear… I do NOT condone bullying this kid! I’m critiquing the producers, not him. They’re the ones who cast a kid with veneer-like teeth. Further proof they don’t know what they’re doing.”
McDowell also shared an edited, AI-generated image of McLaughlin with what he described as a more “age-appropriate” smile. He said the edited version made the casting feel better to him, while repeating that the issue was with the producers, not the child.
The post used the cover image from HBO Max’s official teaser for Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone. It quickly drew attention, partly because of its subject and partly because of its timing. HBO had just shared new footage from the series on November 14, during the 2026 Kids’ Choice Awards. The clip showed Harry, Ron, and Hermione at the Great Hall feast, along with John Lithgow as Dumbledore and Janet McTeer as Professor McGonagall.
Fans Fire Back at the Critique
Replies to the post questioned why an adult was focusing on a child’s teeth at all. The tone ranged from disbelief to outright frustration.
“This is weird thing to be obsessing over” — @smez620382
“You hating a kid for his good teeth. Maybe touch grass :)” — @usersoontm
“Here we go again with the ‘i mean no harm’ but proceeds to say the some criticism that is destructive to the poor kid.” — @Ameererrh09
“I’m all for criticizing aesthetics in modern movies but this might be a bit of a stretch” — @Rational_Obs
“Having an opinion on the physical look of an 11 year old is weird. Talk about the acting of something” — @BigDerrickBando
Another reply pointed out the obvious: McLaughlin is not Daniel Radcliffe, and he should not be expected to be.
“people just need to get used to seeing this kid as harry and not Daniel Radcliffe” — @thedanielbp
The criticism also drew attention on TikTok and Reddit, where users repeated a similar point. A child’s appearance should not be treated as a casting flaw to be workshopped online.
A Pattern of Scrutiny for a 12-Year-Old
The teeth post was not an isolated comment. It followed months of similar remarks about McLaughlin’s smile, stretching back to the show’s early promotional material.
Bored Panda reported that fans had previously called his smile “creepy” and questioned whether his teeth were real. Some users said the teeth looked like dentures. Others asked whether an 11-year-old could naturally have teeth that straight.
By October 2026, fans claimed McLaughlin had started smiling with his mouth closed in public photos. Two images, taken nearly a year apart, were compared side by side. One showed him at a screening of Grow in London on October 5, 2025. The other was from the 2026 Abbey Road Music Photography Awards in September 2026. In the newer photo, his lips were closed.
“They talked so much about the boy’s tooth that he learned to smile with his mouth closed at 12 years old. The internet is the true Voldemort.” — a comment shared by Bored Panda
“He has such a beautiful smile too, but now he doesn’t open his mouth anymore so his teeth show, poor thing.” — another comment
McLaughlin’s Instagram account, his only public social media presence, was deactivated in early October 2026. A fan updates account stated that his parents made the decision. No official reason was given by the family or HBO.
Daniel Radcliffe’s Message to the New Cast
Daniel Radcliffe has publicly backed McLaughlin and the rest of the young cast. Radcliffe was 11 when he was cast in the original films, so he knows the pressure that comes with the role.
“I’m sure Dominic is going to be better than me. I learned as I went. I look back on what I did now with a lot more kindness, and I find it less interesting now that I’m older. But I was very much learning how to do it for a long time on ‘Potter.’”
Radcliffe also asked fans to stop measuring the new cast against him and Rupert Grint.
“I would like not to be weird spectral phantoms in these children’s lives, and just to let them, like, get on it. Because it’s going to be a new thing.”
McLaughlin himself has called the role a dream come true.
“I was always a huge Harry Potter fan when I was younger. And it was like the dream role, of course.” — Dominic McLaughlin, to the BBC
The Clip That Started the Latest Round
HBO released the banquet clip on Saturday, November 14, 2026, during the Kids’ Choice Awards broadcast. The 90-second scene shows students chanting Dumbledore’s name, Harry asking Ron whether the headmaster is “a bit mad,” and Ron replying, “Yep, totally off his rocker.” Dumbledore snaps his fingers, and food appears on the tables.
Reactions to the clip were divided well before the teeth post. Some fans criticized the lighting and color grading, calling the scene “soulless” compared to the 2001 film. Others defended the new footage and said it was unfair to judge an eight-part series on one short scene.
You May Also Like:
When the Series Arrives
Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone premieres on December 25, 2026 on HBO in the United States and on HBO Max in the UK, Canada, Australia, and other global markets. Indian viewers can watch it on JioHotstar from December 26, 2026.
The first season has eight episodes. HBO has already ordered a second season, based on Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets.
Francesca Gardiner is the showrunner and executive producer. Mark Mylod directs and executive produces. Hans Zimmer is composing the music. The cast includes Dominic McLaughlin as Harry, Arabella Stanton as Hermione, Alastair Stout as Ron, John Lithgow as Dumbledore, Janet McTeer as McGonagall, Paapa Essiedu as Snape, and Nick Frost as Hagrid.
Also Read: HBO’s Harry Potter Series Faces Backlash Over Missing Floating Candles: “They Ruined It”
For more entertainment news and updates on the Harry Potter series, keep reading VvipTimes.




































Leave a Reply