The new opening credits sequence for Peacemaker Season 2 has sparked strong reactions from fans and critics. The updated dance number, set to the song “Oh Lord” by Foxy Shazam, replaces the first season’s widely popular “Do Ya Wanna Taste It” by Wig Wam. While some viewers appreciate the fresh approach, many others have expressed disappointment, calling it a “big downgrade” compared to the original viral sensation.
James Gunn, the creator of Peacemaker and co-CEO of DC Studios, had expressed nervousness about creating a new opening sequence. He acknowledged that the first season’s dance number was a surprise that could not be replicated. Gunn stated:
“People say, ‘How are you going to one-up the first season?’ You can’t one-up the first season because, truth is, people didn’t know a dance scene was coming” .
The new credits are longer, clocking in at 105 seconds compared to the first season’s 80 seconds, and feature both returning and new cast members. Choreographer Charissa-Lee Barton returned to create the routine, which includes more story elements related to Season 2’s plot .
Fan Reactions to the New Sequence
Many fans took to social media and online forums to share their thoughts on the new opening. A common criticism focused on the song choice, with numerous viewers feeling that “Oh Lord” does not match the energy or tone of the first season’s “Do Ya Wanna Taste It.” Some comments included:
“Love the dance, but completely the wrong song. It just doesnโt feel right” .
“It gives off a vibe like they originally planned to have a better/more fitting song there, but then they couldnโt get the rights to it so they had to opt for a soundalike at the last minute” .
“The Season 2 intro is fineโฆ However, a fun thing to do is watch Frank Grillo. At Comic-Con it was revealed that he was the worst dancer of the cast, and you will be amazed at how much he sticks out” .
Others noted that the choreography itself was well-executed but was let down by the music. The emotional, ballad-like nature of “Oh Lord” was seen as a poor fit for the high-energy, quirky dance moves that characterized the first season’s opening .
How the New Credits Compare to Season 1
The first season’s opening credits became an internet sensation. The unexpected dance sequence, set to the glam rock anthem “Do Ya Wanna Taste It,” was praised for its originality, humor, and the commitment of the cast. It featured all main characters, including John Cena and Jennifer Holland, performing with deadpan expressions .
The Season 2 sequence attempts to build on this formula but with a different tone. It introduces new characters like Frank Grillo’s Rick Flag Sr. and Tim Meadows’ Langston Fleury. It also includes hints about the season’s multiverse plotline, showing alternate versions of characters like Harcourt and Auggie Smith .
Despite these creative choices, the general consensus among critical fans is that the new sequence fails to capture the same magic. The shift from a catchy, upbeat rock song to a more somber rock ballad is seen as the primary reason for the weaker impact .
The Creator’s Perspective
James Gunn has been open about the challenge of following up the first season’s success. He explained that he listened to many songs before selecting “Oh Lord” by Foxy Shazam, which he has called his favorite band. Gunn believed the new song’s lyrics and mood were more relevant to Season 2’s story .
“I really went back and forth an awful lot. And at the end of the day, I decided that we use a new song thatโs a little bit more about what the seasonโs about” .
Gunn also emphasized that the new dance sequence was designed to include the expanded cast and reflect the emotional depth of the new season, which explores themes of grief, alternate realities, and redemption .
Overall Response and Season 2 Premiere
The response to the opening credits has been part of a larger conversation about Peacemaker Season 2. The premiere episode, which aired on August 21, 2025, on HBO Max, has received mixed reviews. Some critics found the season premiere to be overly bleak and tonally inconsistent, especially following the more hopeful tone of Gunn’s recent Superman film .
However, the series continues to be praised for John Cena’s performance and its willingness to take creative risks. The second season aims to delve deeper into the emotional struggles of Christopher Smith (Peacemaker) as he grapples with his past and the consequences of his actions .
While the new opening credits may not have universally pleased fans, they have certainly succeeded in getting people talking. The sequence remains a bold and signature element of James Gunn’s unique style.
Also Read: White Rabbit Joins Peacemaker Season 2 and Could Change Batmanโs DC Universe Future
Credits: tvline.com, gamesradar.com, techadvisor.com
