The second episode of FX’s Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette delivers on the promise of drama as the false sense of control that both main characters thought they had completely shatters. Episode 2, titled “The Pools Party,” jumps ahead several months after that magical first date, and things have gotten incredibly complicated for everyone involved. Carolyn Bessette (Sarah Pidgeon) is done waiting around for John, and she makes that very clear when he starts sending apology roses to her office at Calvin Klein .
The episode opens with a montage set to En Vogue’s “My Lovin’ (You’re Never Gonna Get It),” showing delivery men showing up at Carolyn’s workplace with vase after vase of long-stemmed red roses. Each card from John pleads with her to forgive him, insisting “It’s not what you think” about those tabloid photos showing him with ex-girlfriend Daryl Hannah (Dree Hemingway). Carolyn, who has now been promoted high enough at Calvin Klein to have her own assistant named Rachel (Haley Root), refuses every single delivery . The message is crystal clear—John’s not getting back in her good graces that easily.
Carolyn and John’s Awkward Reunion at the Pools Party
The tension between Carolyn and John reaches its peak when they unexpectedly run into each other at a party celebrating a coffee table book called Pools, curated by Kelly Klein (Leila George), Calvin’s wife. Carolyn has organized the entire event, and it’s packed with hunky male models wearing nothing but Calvin Klein briefs . Among them is Michael Bergin (Noah Fearnley), a John lookalike who catches Carolyn’s attention despite the dozens of voicemails from him she’s been ignoring.
When John makes a grand entrance, Carolyn remains cool as can be. She teases him about showing up, joking that she was hoping it would be Prince instead. John perks up, asking if the musician is actually supposed to attend, but Carolyn shuts him down with a perfect line: “Do you think Prince RSVPs?” . He tries to ask about the roses he sent, but she tells him they weren’t necessary, adding that Calvin only permits white orchids in the office anyway.
John follows her when she tries to make an elegant exit, and Carolyn’s carefully constructed mask finally slips a little. She tells him she assumes his girlfriend Daryl understands the weird fishbowl he lives in, and if she were John, she wouldn’t want to give that up either . She suggests they should just be friends. John desperately says he wishes he had been someone else when he met Carolyn, but she keeps her composure, replying, “It is what it is. I’ll see you around” .
Executive producer Brad Simpson explained the show’s approach to Carolyn and John’s relationship timeline in a recent interview. “In reality, they were on again, off again, a little bit more than we had time to do in the show,” Simpson told USA TODAY. “But we needed to jump ahead, and we didn’t feel like the audience wanted to see the stop and starts of their romance” . So viewers can expect more passion to heat up soon.
John’s Struggles with Career and Relationships
Meanwhile, John is trying to get his magazine George off the ground. He’s now 33 years old, and he and his business partner Michael J. Berman (Michael Nathanson) are pitching the concept to publishing executives over lunch. The idea is to cover the intersection of politics and pop culture, with A-list celebrities on covers playfully nodding to American history . One executive makes a cringe-worthy comment about seeing Daryl Hannah in a sexy Salem witch outfit before both suits reject the idea. They tell John that Americans won’t buy a magazine about politics unless he wants to go the Martha Stewart Living route and put his own face on every cover. John takes the suggestion personally—he knows his looks sell, but he wants to be taken seriously .
Later, John complains about this to his friend Anthony in the gym locker room. Their conversation gets interrupted when someone rushes in to tell John that his mother Jackie (Naomi Watts) is in the hospital. She was thrown from a horse during a fox hunting trip in Virginia . The doctor questions Jackie about her health, and when she brags about her fitness and diet, Caroline (Grace Gummer) blurts out that her mother smokes. Jackie dismisses her companion Maurice (Adam Grupper) and Caroline so she can hassle John in private about his new project. She doesn’t understand why he’d want to break into the industry that has profited off his family’s misery for decades, especially after he finally passed the bar exam . John defends himself, saying his father wanted to be a journalist before his grandfather Joe roped him into politics.
A USA TODAY fact-check confirms that Jackie’s horse-riding accident was real. In November 1993, Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis fell while fox hunting in Virginia when her horse attempted to jump a crumbling wall. A friend named Barbara Graham told Edward Klein’s 2004 book “Farewell, Jackie” that “Jackie’s horse took off well back from the wall. He was trying to avoid the fallen stones, I guess. He basically landed on his nose, and she catapulted right over his head” .
The Messy Daryl Hannah Situation at Family Dinner
Back at John’s apartment, things aren’t going well with Daryl either. When John returns home, he finds her doing a headstand surrounded by friends, next to a silver tray with plenty of cocaine residue . He’s already upset from his disappointing run-in with Carolyn, so he testily excuses himself to crash in the bedroom loft, which is completely open to the rest of the apartment. Daryl follows him, and they start blaming each other for making them both miserable. She tells him she just wants him to need her as much as she needs him. When he doesn’t understand, she fires back, “That’s because you’re repressed….Between your lineage and your heritage, you’re, like, the poster child for emotional avoidance” .
The tension boils over at a family dinner at Jackie’s apartment. Daryl joins John, Caroline, and her husband Edwin Schlossberg (Ben Shenkman), but Jackie’s seat remains empty. A staff member informs them that Jackie will be dining in her room. Daryl storms out, screaming at John in the street that it’s obvious why Jackie might be prejudiced against blonde actresses. “She wants you to choose her. She wants you to find YOUR Jackie,” Daryl yells .
Fan reactions on social media have been mixed about this scene. One viewer on the Fangirlish review commented, “I woulda dumped her there. I was glad that she threw her fit and left” . The confrontation cuts deep, referencing the late President John F. Kennedy’s infamous affair with Marilyn Monroe.
According to fact-checking from USA TODAY, Jim Hart, a friend of Jackie’s, shared in “JFK Jr.: An Intimate Oral Biography” that the matriarch “was not a fan of that relationship.” Hart continued, “It wasn’t like she hated Daryl at all. She just didn’t want her son marrying an actress − it kind of was that simple. There was no great animosity, but she was always talking about ‘What do you think of Daryl? Do you think that’s right for John?’” .
When Daryl gets home first, she tells John she’s leaving for Los Angeles. She wonders if her current career lull might be “the universe” making space for her to support John in his next chapter, but she also points out that it’s been five years and if John wanted to marry her he would have . He accuses her of trying to manipulate him with her public wedding dress shopping, but she fires back that not everything is a machination of the Kennedy court. She leaves, saying she’ll be back for her dog Hank in a few days and telling John to think about what HE wants.
Carolyn’s Growing Connection with Michael Bergin
While John deals with relationship chaos, Carolyn is opening up to someone new. After the Pools party, she ends up in bed with Michael Bergin . During an intimate moment, she pinches his pec, and when he asks why she always does that, she shares a vulnerable story from her childhood. She recalls playing hide and seek as a kid and hiding so well that no one found her—because they forgot her. The realization sent her into a panic attack, and her mother told her to pinch her arm to focus on something else, which eventually worked . Michael tells her he never would have stopped looking for her, which seems to spook Carolyn into shutting down again.
The next morning, Carolyn sees John being interviewed on the Today show and gets an idea. She brings Michael to the empty Calvin Klein showroom over the weekend and dresses him up like a Ken doll . As he does pull-ups on a scaffold outside, Carolyn looks past him to the plywood covered with Marky Mark Wahlberg’s Calvin Klein posters and gets inspired.
The timing works out perfectly because Marky Mark just caused a scandal. In the episode, he punched Guy Oseary, head of Madonna’s record label, and verbally abused another member of her entourage . A Calvin Klein suit named Todd (Richard Neil) dismisses the incident, noting Mark “only called the guy a homo,” implying he meant a homophobic slur. Carolyn sarcastically responds, “Yeah, he’s practically Harvey Milk” . Calvin’s wife Kelly gets nervous when Calvin says they need to fire Mark and issue a statement condemning him, but Calvin flinches away when she touches his arm.
Mark’s replacement should be a fresh face, not another celebrity. Todd smugly notes that since Calvin plucked Kate Moss from obscurity, he can certainly mint another star. Carolyn ruefully absorbs this erasure of her part in Kate’s success—she has a model to smuggle out of Moscow. Too bad she’s not currently on speaking terms with someone who can probably get Bill Clinton on the phone .
Carolyn later brings Michael to his go-see for Calvin, dressing him in brand-new Calvin Klein duds and helping him nail the audition. Later, she’s contemplating a wall full of possible replacements for Mark when her assistant Rachel brings her a vase of white orchids with a card. It reads, “Hoping pleasantries are still an option – Sadly not Prince” . Carolyn hides the card when Michael enters and tells Rachel the flowers can stay at her desk this time.
According to Elizabeth Beller’s book “Once Upon a Time: The Captivating Life of Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy,” which the series is based on, Carolyn really did have a relationship with Michael Bergin. “In the fall of 1992, Carolyn began a casual romance with model Michael Bergin,” Beller writes. “A former hotel doorman at the Paramount, Bergin would later, in a tell-all book, ‘The Other Man,’ claim he was sexually involved with Carolyn from the fall of ’92 until her death” . However, Beller adds that “There’s no doubt Carolyn befriended Bergin, and, true to form, helped him with his career. Carolyn and Michael had an on-off relationship, much more off than on. His later account of it is considered questionable by many of Carolyn’s friends.”
Tragedy Strikes on Two Fronts
The episode’s most devastating moments come at the end. John is walking Daryl’s dog Hank when a fan stops him for an autograph. The fan wants John to sign his “Sexiest Man Alive” People magazine cover, and the distraction causes John to let go of Hank’s leash . John chases the dog but can’t stop him from running into the street, directly into the path of a cab. Soon John is on the phone giving a hysterical Daryl the bad news and saying he’s on his way to Los Angeles with Hank’s remains.
As John rushes to leave, he misses a phone call. The answering machine picks up, and it’s Jackie trying to smooth things over after boycotting that dinner with Daryl. She hangs up and suddenly swoons, taking a few steps before crumpling to the floor. Her housekeeper Eugie finds her collapsed . The episode ends with John brooding on an airplane, Hank’s urn in his lap, completely unaware that his mother has just had a medical emergency back in New York.
The real-life story behind Hank’s death is just as tragic. Sasha Chermayeff, a friend of John’s, described the incident in “JFK Jr.: An Intimate Oral Biography.” “He’d been walking it in the city, in Central Park. The dog got off the leash and got hit by a car and died. Daryl was devastated” . Another friend, Steven Gillon, added that John brought the dog’s ashes from New York to LA. “So he goes out there to bury the dog. And while he’s out there, his mom has a dramatic turn for the worse. He was deeply resentful that Daryl dragged him out there to attend a funeral for her dog when his mother was dying of cancer” .
In real life, Jackie was diagnosed with non-Hodgkins lymphoma. She passed away on May 19, 1994, at age 64 .
Also Read:
What Viewers Are Saying About Episode 2
Fans have been sharing their thoughts about the episode on social media and forums. One viewer on the YOHO Community forum noted the show’s blend of real and fictional elements, particularly the depiction of Daryl Hannah’s drug use, questioning whether this reflects how contemporary culture deconstructs celebrity private lives . Another fan on Fangirlish praised the show’s ability to keep viewers engaged despite knowing these are dramatized versions of real people. “You will find yourself captivated with what is happening – even though you know that this is a dramatized version of their love story,” they wrote .
The bedroom scene where Carolyn opens up to Michael about her childhood panic attack resonated with many viewers. One reviewer noted, “The in bed scene where Caroline lets her walls down I thought was sweet” . The moment provides crucial backstory for why Carolyn keeps people at arm’s length, making her guarded personality more understandable.
The episode also sparked discussion about Calvin Klein’s character and his own struggles. After the party, Kelly complains to Carolyn about Calvin’s post-rehab sanctimony regarding her Diet Coke consumption. He’s still relatively fresh out of treatment for “alcohol and prescription drug abuse” he entered in 1988 . The show hints at the designer’s ongoing issues, which would later make headlines in 2004 when his erratic behavior at a Knicks basketball game briefly forced a halt in play, leading to what became known as the “Calvin Klein bill” in New York City .
As Episode 2 closes, the false sense of control that both John and Carolyn thought they had is completely gone. Carolyn tried to protect herself by keeping John at a distance, but those white orchids suggest she’s not as over him as she pretends to be. John thought he could balance his relationship with Daryl while pursuing his magazine dreams and keeping his family happy, but now he’s flying to Los Angeles with a dog’s ashes while his mother lies unconscious on the floor back home. The stage is set for even more drama as the series continues.
New episodes of Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette air Thursdays on FX at 9 PM ET/PT and stream on Hulu the next day .
For more celebrity news, TV show recaps, and exclusive entertainment updates, keep reading VvipTimes.
