The Netflix dating show Love Is Blind has kept fans hooked since its start in 2020 with its unique setup of people falling in love in pods without seeing each other. Over seven seasons, it has delivered plenty of drama, from pod fights to post-engagement blowups. These moments often divide audiences, leading to online buzz and calls for changes in how the show handles relationships. Here are seven standout controversies that had everyone talking.
Carlton Mortensen’s Pod Blowup in Season 1
In the first season, which aired in February 2020, Carlton Mortensen and Diamond Jack seemed like a solid match after getting engaged in the pods. Things took a turn when Carlton revealed he was bisexual during a Mexico trip. Diamond felt blindsided because he had not shared this earlier. The conversation escalated quickly into a heated argument by the pool, with Carlton throwing the ring at her and walking away.
Viewers split on this one. Some praised Diamond for wanting full honesty from the start, while others thought Carlton’s reaction showed deeper issues. The fight became a key talking point about trust in the experiment. Carlton later said in interviews that editing made it look worse, but fans still reference it as a raw example of pod pressures.
This moment set the tone for how personal disclosures can explode on camera. It aired during a time when the show was new, and many tuned in for the fallout.
Giannina Gibelli’s Wedding Day Chaos in Season 1
Season 1’s finale in Mexico brought one of the show’s most talked-about scenes. Giannina Gibelli and Damian Powers had a rocky road after the pods, with arguments over trust and outside connections. At the altar on April 2020, Damian said no, citing unresolved doubts.
Giannina ran out crying, only to slip and fall into a huge mud puddle outside the chapel. She got up, covered in dirt, and confronted Damian again. The image of her mud-soaked dress went viral, symbolizing the emotional mess of the show.
Fans debated if the rejection was fair or if production pushed them too far. Giannina later shared on social media that the fall hurt physically, but the heartbreak stung more. This scene, from the episodes released in March 2020, remains a meme favorite and a reminder of the high stakes at weddings.
Shake Chatterjee’s Attraction Comments in Season 2
Season 2, which dropped in February 2022, introduced Abhishek “Shake” Chatterjee and Deepti Vempati. They connected in the pods, but after meeting face-to-face in Mexico, Shake admitted he did not feel physical attraction. He even told other guys he would not want to see Deepti in a bikini, sparking body-shaming accusations.
At the altar in May 2022, Shake said no, and Deepti chose herself in a empowering turnaround. The comments drew backlash for being cruel, especially since Shake pursued her initially.
Viewers called out the insensitivity, with many on platforms like Reddit saying it highlighted shallow judgments. Shake defended himself on podcasts, claiming he was honest, but the damage stuck. This moment, from episodes aired in 2022, fueled talks on consent and respect in dating shows.
Season 4 Reunion Technical Glitches
The live reunion for Season 4 in April 2023 turned into a disaster when technical problems hit. Hosted by Nick Lachey and Vanessa Lachey, the event from Chicago aimed to wrap up the season’s drama with couples like Tiffany Pennywell and Brett Brown. But audio cuts, frozen screens, and connection fails left fans frustrated.
Over 1,000 complaints flooded Netflix’s support, with viewers missing key updates on marriages and breakups. The show promised a rebroadcast, but many felt it ruined the closure.
This controversy, tied to the April 16, 2023, airing, exposed production flaws in live events. Cast members like Jackie Goldschneider later joked about it online, but it led to questions about Netflix’s tech readiness for reality TV.
Trevor’s Catfish Reveal in Season 6
Season 6, filmed in Charlotte and aired starting January 2024, featured Trevor Sova, who pursued Taylor Rue in the pods. At the reunion on March 13, 2024, Trevor’s ex-girlfriend exposed him as a liar. He had a girlfriend outside the show and faked being single, even using old photos.
Taylor felt tricked, and fans raged over the deception. Trevor admitted to stretching the truth but denied full catfishing. The reveal came after episodes showed his charm, making the twist hit hard.
This moment, from the 2024 reunion, boosted discussions on cast screening. Social media lit up with calls for better background checks, as it questioned the show’s authenticity.
Chelsea Blackwell’s Lookalike Drama in Season 6
In the same Season 6, Chelsea Blackwell caught heat for comparing herself to Megan Fox during a girls’ trip in Mexico. Her pod partner Jimmy Presnell called her out, saying she looked more like Kylie Jenner. The back-and-forth became a viral clip after the February 2024 episodes.
Chelsea defended it as a joke, but Jimmy’s response seemed harsh, leading to their breakup. Fans debated if it was petty or a sign of mismatched vibes.
The drama peaked in episodes 5 and 6, aired in February 2024, and spilled into podcasts. It showed how small comments can derail connections under the show’s spotlight.
Tyler’s Hidden Kids in Season 7
Season 7, set in Washington D.C. and airing from August 2024, brought Tyler Green and Ashley Diaz. They seemed strong until the reunion in March 2025, where Ashley learned Tyler had three kids from past relationships he never mentioned.
Ashley said she would have walked away if told earlier. Tyler explained it as protecting privacy, but viewers saw it as a major red flag. The secret surfaced after their Mexico honeymoon, adding to trust issues.
This 2025 reveal, from recent episodes, has fans questioning family disclosures. Cast updates show Ashley and Tyler split soon after, with her sharing on Instagram about moving on.
These moments capture why Love Is Blind stays relevant, blending romance with real conflicts. As of September 2025, Season 8 reunions are wrapping up, with more cast interviews dropping on Netflix’s Tudum site. The show continues to film new batches, keeping the pod drama alive.
Also Read: Love Is Blind UK Season 2 Cast Revealed: Meet All 30 Singles Looking for Love
