The global girl group KATSEYE is dealing with a wave of tough criticism after music reviewers tore apart their latest release. The group, formed under HYBE and Geffen Records, dropped their new EP Wild and immediately faced some of the most brutal feedback of their career.
One major music publication gave the EP a 4.5 out of 10 rating. This score has been called one of the lowest ever given to a girl group album. The review did not hold back, criticizing everything from the songs to the vocals and the group’s overall identity.
The review described the EP as trying to create excitement and disorder but failing to cover up what it called an “inner emptiness”. It also said the rest of the EP struggles between outdated cultural references and embarrassing moments.
Brutal Review Points Out Vocal and Production Problems
The criticism went deep into how the music was made and performed. Reviewers pointed out that the five members sounded like they were “reading lines from a script” instead of singing with real feeling. One member, Daniela, sings a line in Portuguese, but the review said it felt fake and not genuine.
The production also received harsh words. The review said the group’s version of one track was weighed down by “constipated bass”. Another song, co-written by Ed Sheeran, was called a collection of lyrical and instrumental clichés. The review said the song reminded them more of sitting at a mall food court than anything meaningful.
The vocal performances were also picked apart. The review noted that the voices on the EP start to blend together and sound similar. It described some vocals as “shrill” and said the harmonies often feel forced. One specific part with members Lara and Yoonchae was described as having an “uncanny alien texture”.
Critics Question Group’s Identity and Direction
The main concern from reviewers is that KATSEYE has not developed a clear identity. The review called the EP “another perfectly hollow pop record” that does not bring listeners closer to understanding the members’ personalities. It argued that the music feels like it could have been performed by anyone and means nothing personal to the group.
Another publication also weighed in, describing the music as “placeless, breathy, and willfully cringe”. They said the music is meant to represent young people today but instead comes across as random TikTok content. The phrase “RNG TikTok fodder” has been used to describe the EP.
The review also pointed out that the group relies too heavily on internet references and current trends instead of building a real musical identity. This is not the first time this concern has been raised. A previous review of their earlier EP Beautiful Chaos also said the group’s music could feel generic.
Low User Scores Add to the Pressure
The negative reaction is not just from professional critics. Listeners on Rate Your Music have given Wild a score of 1.97 out of 5. This low user score shows that many everyday listeners also feel disappointed with the release.
The score is based on user ratings rather than official reviews. It adds to the growing online conversation about the EP’s songwriting and production quality. Fans and casual listeners alike have been sharing their thoughts across social media platforms.
Fan Reactions Show Mixed Feelings
Social media has been buzzing with reactions to the harsh reviews. Some fans agreed with the criticism, while others defended the group.
“A manufactured pop group that hasn’t written any of their songs or production has no personality or soul??? Who would have thought”
“they way nobody’s gonna criticize pitchfork this time bc music legit garbage”
Some fans expressed concern about the group’s direction and the quality of their music. Others pointed fingers at HYBE, saying the company is responsible for the group’s problems.
Related:
Group Faces Multiple Controversies
The bad reviews come during a difficult time for KATSEYE. The group has faced several controversies in recent months. One major issue is the criticism over the sexualization of the group’s minor members. Fans have called out the company for inappropriate choreography, imagery, and lyrics.
Their recent music video for “Hootie Frutti” sparked strong backlash. Viewers said the video had too many sexual images. Some fans were angry because the group still has underage members. One person wrote that the outfits and dance moves were not suitable for younger audiences.
The group also faced criticism for a dangerous headbanging move during a live performance on the TODAY show. Fans flagged the choreography as risky and unsafe.
Member Manon Bannerman is currently on hiatus. Her absence from key group activities has also led to fan complaints about how the company treats her.
Mixed Reviews from Other Publications
Not all reviews have been completely negative. NME described Wild as a step toward a clearer sound and praised its experimental dance-pop production. However, even that review noted the project feels conflicted in places.
This split in opinions shows that KATSEYE’s appeal works best for listeners who enjoy energetic production and catchy hooks. But critics remain unconvinced that the group’s internet-focused approach creates a strong artistic identity.
High Expectations Following Past Success
The tough reception comes after KATSEYE experienced significant success with their previous work. Their earlier EP Beautiful Chaos helped establish them as a rising force in global pop. Songs like “Gnarly” received positive attention and were named among the best songs of 2025 by several major publications.
But the new EP’s reception shows that commercial success does not always mean critical approval. The group now faces the challenge of proving they can grow beyond the novelty of being a global girl group.
Wild may strengthen their existing pop formula, but early responses suggest critics and some listeners are asking whether that formula will be enough for long-term growth.
Also Read: KATSEYE’s Sophia Laforteza Takes Temporary Hiatus for Mental Health Recovery
Stay connected with VvipTimes for the latest updates on K-pop groups, music reviews, and entertainment news.
Source: Pitchfork
Leave a Reply